Luminescent,
Without passion most forums would be pretty dull places. I've followed your posts and respect your knowledge. Check you PM's, I've sent you some background that may clarify my post.
Regards
shakeylegs
I got your private message, and now see how the misunderstanding occurred.
I apologize, as something got lost in translation, and it seems it was a misunderstanding on my part of the points your friend at Fenix in Japan was making.
Some time back there were no Rebel-100's available at all, so the choice was between something like a Q4 CREE and the R80.
In this comparison, the R80 could well indeed be "Just as good" because of exactly the Vf issues you mentioned. I.E. although the R80 has less lumens at 350mA, it has only slightly less Lumens/watt because of it's lower Vf, and if the L0D boost converter works better at the lower Vf anyway, then the R80 Rebel could indeed look pretty good against the Q4 or Q5 CREE.
This however does not say anything about the Rebel-80 vs. Rebel-100, because the Rebel-100 can do even MORE lumens/watt and it KEEPS the lower Vf advantage of the earlier Rebel-80.
At this point I can't see any reason at all not to assume that the Rebel-100 is just about IDEAL for the L0D light, and I would urge anyone who has a Rebel edition L0D on order from Fenix to contact them and tell them that you expect that your L0D will come with a Rebel 100 AT THE SAME PRICE, or they can just cancel the order, thank you.
The best way to make an impression on Fenix, is to hit them in their pocket book and simply refuse to accept mediocre quality when better should be available.
There are 5 mode Rebel-100 MTE lights on DX now selling for 18 dollars, so if Fenix can't ship the almost 3 times as expensive L0D with a Rebel-100 emitter, then something is seriously wrong.
By the way, for those who figure that Fenix is just being honest, and those other evil so-and-so's are probably just ripping people off, please note, unlike the 'who the hell knows' situation with the CREE Q5, the Rebel-100 can be positively identified, even if the manufacture covers the chip except for the dome, by the tiny checkerboard pattern dots on the surface of the phosphor, which are easy to spot using a 10x loop.
All Rebel chips with these dots should be Rebel-100 or later chips (at least 100 lumens/watt), because this is the LOWEST bin for these new series chips, and the older Rebel-80, Rebel-50 and lower bin Rebel series chips lack this pattern.
The cheepy MTE Rebel-100 lights I have seen DO pass this test, so I would hope that Fenix will.