<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>What caused the change in consumer price was that SF set a min. discount off list so the distributers couldn't sell the lights at "dealer" cost<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
That is called resale price maintenance.. when a manufacturer (in this case SF) forces retailers to sell goods at a minimum price set by the manufacturer. This is *prohibited* by law in Australia and I'd be surprised if it wasn't the same in the US. SF can only recommend a minimum price but any attempts to enforce it (by cancelling a supply agreement for example) would breach the law.
My gut feeling is that SF jacked up prices to the dealers as all the evidence seems to point in this direction.
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>YES, and definately YES!<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>No.. seriously? Here are my opinions:
Shock-isolated bezel
--------------------
According to several comments made by CPF members, it seems like this feature (the bits of rubber to soften the impact) doesn't work very well. The Scorpion has a rubber ring around the bulb which could also help "isolate" the bulb from a severe shock. Even the UK2L has more "shock isolation" than the M2.
Recharge kit
------------
Yeah for the price of a new rechargable torch.
Option 1 - Get an C2 with a recharger kit (and end up with 1 switchable torch)
or
Option 2 - Get a Scorpion AND a Stinger (plus several bulbs and lithium batteries to even out the price difference!)
Filter and beamshapers
----------------------
How many of you SF owners have AND use the filters and beamshapers regularly. I'm betting only a small percentage. If you really want coloured lights, use a Luxeon. You'll get more light with infinitely longer runtime (well about 5x anyway).
Type III anodising
------------------
I'd take the rubber sleeve of the Scorpion anyday. You get a much more secure grip, its a lot easier to keep it looking new and it never feels cold to the touch.
Bulb
----
16 hours for P60... are you sure about that? I've never seen that anywhere else.
Beam quality
------------
This issue is debateable. SFs have a larger hotspot with a small spill beam. The opposite is true for the Scorpion. Which one you prefer is up to you as I wouldn't mind either.
Optional bulb
-------------
Nice idea but when the runtime is reduced to 20 minutes for a $5 set of batteries (or $10 if you don't shop around), its just not economical. Even 1 hour of runtime at $5 is pretty steep.
This is probably why other manufacturers who choose to make small/powerful torches make them rechargable. The $/lumen figure for torches using lithiums is *very* high in comparison.
Lockout tailcap
---------------
OK you win here. This is the only feature in SFs that I think is truly great. Simple, effective but not worth the extra *large* amount of cash.
There you go my opinion. I think thats enough said.