I was right at the same junction a few days ago, 9P vs. C3. I got 9P for an awesome price of about $60. But then I found out it did not have the more durable HA-III finish. Oh well. Its finish seems to hold pretty well. If it starts peeling, I will just apply the NP3 finish by Robar. Should run $50 I would think, which should put me in the same price range as C3 anyway.
has anyone experience 6P or 9P peeling? Would like to see pics if possible.
Now regarding cells, tough choice. I like the compact stock body of 9P. I also want the greater runtime of 2x18500 or better yet 2x18650 but I wonder if it will cease to be an EDC lite with the latter. The stock 9P is kind of pushing it.
I wonder if I should just get 17500 and spares also. You can easily revert to primaries if you have to. Such is not the case with 2x18650. I think with 18500 body, you can still use primaries if you get an insert, as they should be pretty loose inside. Actually 123s are kind of loose inside the stock body, I had to wrap some paper around them so they stay quiet.