There are a LOT of choices in the 1x123 format, and you're going to get a whole range of recommendations.
If you really like the P1D's form and you don't mind also losing multi-mode ability, there's always the Fenix P1 (no D), which is pretty much the same flashlight, slightly smaller, with just the one regulated output mode (90 lumens, ~2 hours). Not quite as bright, but $20 cheaper than the P1D Q5.
https://www.fenix-store.com/product_info.php?cPath=22_69_51&products_id=317
If keeping it small is a prime concern, there's the Lumapower IncenDio Q5, which is just slightly larger than the P1D, but uses a clicky button. It has just three set modes (high-medium-low), no strobe/SOS/flashy settings. Still not as bright, but about $15 cheaper than the P1D Q5.
http://www.batteryjunction.com/incendio.html
If brightness is what you're after, there's the JetBeam Jet-II IBS. This one is notably bigger than the P1D, but can put out 225 lumens (and go all the way down to 2). It uses an infinitely variable brightness control with three memory positions, so you can program in what you want each mode to be (so there's no strobe/SOS mode unless you choose one to be a mode). Using your CPF discount, this one is roughly the same price as the P1D.
http://www.bugoutgearusa.com/jetiiibs.html
Don't forget to check out Selfbuilt's 1x123 shootout:
https://www.candlepowerforums.com/threads/201117
Hope this helps!