Choose a light that has a small diameter reflector and one that's not particularly deep, like the Fenix P1/2/3D or L1/2D. Those all have a relatively large spot and spill. Get the OP reflector rather than smooth one. I put a piece of Scotch "Magic" tape over a P1 which I modified with a Seoul LED, and it's great for walking or camping -- it'll light up a whole camp site. This trick works for most lights, and it reduces the total light output an unnoticeable amount - just 10 - 15%.
OLight has managed to get a small spot with a small diameter reflector, so I wouldn't recommend them for your purpose.
Seoul Semiconductor (SSC) LEDs are generally more floody than Crees, and about as efficient. So any light you can find which has an SSC rather than Cree LED is likely to be closer to what you want.
c_c