“MYO” and “MYO Belt” Headlamps RECALL

chris_m

Enlightened
Joined
Oct 25, 2006
Messages
383
Location
England
So the problem is sparking and melting and the solution is a new warning label? Can anybody explain why a problem with the cable might happen only with rechargeables?
 

DM51

Flashaholic
Joined
Oct 31, 2006
Messages
13,338
Location
Borg cube #51
I was puzzled that the CPSC did not specify what type of rechargeable batteries were causing the problem, so I clicked on the Petzl link given there, rather expecting to read about people having used Li-Ions and the problem being to do with excess voltage.

But it wasn't that. The warning applies to ALL rechargeables, including NiMH. I can't think offhand of any application where Alkaline cells would be OK but NiMH would not, so I'm a bit perplexed by this.
 

hopkins

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
906
Location
California
Petzl's safety idea is that alkaline batteries cannot supply the short circuit
current needed to the wires to melt/burn/ignite flames while rechargeable NimH batteries can. From Petzl web site.

The cable on my old blue model Myo Xp developed an open circuit at the point
it comes out of the headlamp hole-(hinge area) probably due to me tilting
the lamp hinge up and down for hours on end after I bought it. (just to see if the cable would fatigue and fail).

It did.
note: outer black insulation contains a red wire and a black wire.

Doing a repair I found that the cables are the kind with dozens of very fine
wire filiments twisted into a bundle and enclosed inside plastic insulation -duh!
Anyway the insulation had also failed due to my mechanical abuse and a few
of the fine wire filiments were poking out of the red wire. The black wires
insulation had not failed yet but I could tell that the wire cable inside was mostly parted.
So a short circuit was a real possibilty if the black insulation had also opened.

I have and will still use rechargeable NimH batteries because my repair
allows me to see the insulated wires going into the headlamp without being
concealed by the outer insulation of the original Petzl cable. If another
failure happens it'll be obvious at the point the wires go into the hole.
click on pic to see larger.
 
Last edited:

hopkins

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
906
Location
California
Anytime.
Is someone up to the task of safely conducting a short circuit test 'shootout'
between 3 AA alkalines and 3 AA NimH batteries, with maybe a foot of similiar cable,
with the far ends frayed to recreate the kind of short Petzl is worried about.
I would strongly warn CPF'ers not to try this unless you use some kind of blast shield like the MythBusters have...
...and maybe poke the frayed wires together with a stick from the safety of the shield...and do it outside due to the real possibility of toxic smoke!

Have a camera to record the results please.:popcorn::popcorn::popcorn:
 

slvoid

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Oct 29, 2006
Messages
182
Location
Brooklyn, NYC
Stupidest recall ever...

So the thing can short out. Instead of recalling the headlamps and perhaps engineering a headlamp that can't short out, you get a WARNING LABEL to address the problem of rechargeables causing a burn hazard...
 

chris_m

Enlightened
Joined
Oct 25, 2006
Messages
383
Location
England
Ah, that makes sense about alkalines not being able to supply sufficient current to cause a problem. Don't know why I hadn't thought of that - apart from that I wasn't making the connection that the wiring had already failed to cause this problem.

If I owned one of these I would be returning it for a refund even if I'm only supposed to be putting a warning sticker on. If it's no longer suitable for use with NiMH cells, then it's no longer fit for purpose. I'm staggered that a fault which is initially caused by a failure in the wiring doesn't merit a proper recall to actually fix the fault.
 

DM51

Flashaholic
Joined
Oct 31, 2006
Messages
13,338
Location
Borg cube #51
I agree. They save maybe $0.0001 per unit by cheaping out on the wiring, and then just send out a sticker? Extraordinary.
 

Ralph_S

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Sep 23, 2007
Messages
31
...
The cable on my old blue model Myo Xp developed an open circuit at the point
it comes out of the headlamp hole-(hinge area) probably due to me tilting
the lamp hinge up and down for hours on end after I bought it. (just to see if the cable would fatigue and fail).

It did.
note: outer black insulation contains a red wire and a black wire.

Doing a repair I found that the cables are the kind with dozens of very fine
wire filiments twisted into a bundle and enclosed inside plastic insulation -duh!
Anyway the insulation had also failed due to my mechanical abuse and a few
of the fine wire filiments were poking out of the red wire. The black wires
insulation had not failed yet but I could tell that the wire cable inside was mostly parted.
So a short circuit was a real possibilty if the black insulation had also opened.
...

I wonder whether you happened to notice a spring wire in the cable. It feels as though there is some stiffening in the cable, which I guess would reduce vulnerability to bending, but not to the twisting that you applied.
Thanks
 

Illum

Flashaholic
Joined
Apr 29, 2006
Messages
13,053
Location
Central Florida, USA
I agree. They save maybe $0.0001 per unit by cheaping out on the wiring, and then just send out a sticker? Extraordinary.

modding an existing design could consume capital and you would have to voluntarily ship in and out products...shipping will cost something no matter how small scale it is...and all this in and outs may become a liability to the end users who sent them in...supposed they missed one guy...then what?

Whoever designed the light obviously failed at their material science course and the ramification of the designer's flaws will have an extraordinary impact that concerns the reputation of the company:poke:

Sending labels out...is easy but irresponsible, especially since rechargeables are everywhere and many people on the forum [me included] uses rechargeables in electronics that says "alkalines only" because rechargeables will not leak. Eneloops [my favorite cell] will comfortably give 10 amps when shorted...I hate to think what that will be like when its standing on your head:shakehead
 
Last edited:

ltiu

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2007
Messages
1,344
Location
Texas
Energizer e2 Lithium (L91) can supply the current necessary for the problem too!
 
Last edited:

Changchung

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 2, 2005
Messages
2,167
Location
Where the night is too short...
I just receive that message from Amazon;

We have recently learned that Petzl America (Clearfield, UT), in cooperation with the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), is issuing a safety alert for its MYO and MYO Belt Headlamps. Our records indicate that you have purchased one of the headlamps listed in this recall through the Amazon.com website and are therefore affected by this recall.

The recall involves the MYO (battery pack attached to headband) and MYO BELT (remote battery pack attached via long electric cable) headlamps with the following model numbers: MYO (E26P), MYO-BLACK (E26PN), MYO 3 (E27P), MYO 3-BLACK (E27PN), MYO 5 (E28P), MYO 5-BLACK (E28PN), MYO BELT 3 (E29 P), MYO BELT 5 (E30 P), MYOLITE (E31 P), MYOLITE 3 (E32 P), MYOBELT SB5 (E33 P), MYO XP, BLUE (E83 P), MYO XP, GRAY (E83 P2), MYOBELT XP, BLUE (E84 P), and MYO XP BELT, GRAY (E84 P2). They were sold from February 2003 through August 2008 for between $40 and $80.

If the headlamp is used with rechargeable batteries, the cable connecting the battery pack to the lamp can spark, melt, or catch fire.

Petzl is asking consumers to immediately stop using rechargeable batteries with the headlamps and contact Petzl to obtain a new warning label. Consumers can continue to use the headlamps with non-rechargeable batteries. For additional information, contact Petzl America toll-free at (877) 740-3826 between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. MT Monday through Friday, or visit the firm's Web site at www.petzl.com.

You may also find additional details about the recall in the CPSC bulletin at: www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/prerel/prhtml08/08403.html.

If you purchased this item as a gift for someone, please notify the recipient immediately and provide them with the information in the CPSC bulletin concerning these safety issues.

We regret the inconvenience this recall has caused you but trust you will understand that the safety of our customers is our highest priority.

I am using my headlamp with rechargables for a while without any problem yet...
 

Changchung

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 2, 2005
Messages
2,167
Location
Where the night is too short...
I am going to do what hopkins do... Replace the wire and forget about any problem...

That is right, this recall dont resolve the problem, the wire can be broken any time... :thumbsdow
 

276

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
Messages
1,550
Location
CT
I have never used rechargeable's with mine so i should be fine, but thats sucks!
 

hopkins

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
906
Location
California
Does anyone else think that this headlamp battery-cable melting/burning
danger could also apply to all other brands of headlamps (w/ cable
connected battery packs). Not just Petzl.

Can we expect Princeton Tech (Apex) and BlackDiamond (Icon) to announce
a ban on the use of rechargeable batteries to save themselves the hassle
of a lawsuit for injury.

--:candle:want to bet that the lithium pack for the Apex pro could really get the flames
going in a damaged/shorted cable. I picture dripping molten plastic onto my
eyebrow..the horror!:eek:
 
Last edited:

slvoid

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Oct 29, 2006
Messages
182
Location
Brooklyn, NYC
Yeah but unlike the other companies, petzl seems to have designed the product poorly as to allow the cables to fray and short.

As a mechanical engineer designing mechanisms that weigh hundreds of pounds into commercial spaces that hang above people's heads, it would be like me designing a faulty ceiling fixture and instead of a) recalling it and putting in a new one or b) designing it right in the first place, I issue a statement to all the GC's saying "hey, make sure you place tables under the fixtures and not seats, so it doesn't kill anyone, ok?"
 

hopkins

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
906
Location
California
Yeah but unlike the other companies, petzl seems to have designed the product poorly as to allow the cables to fray and short.
"
You got that right Slvoid. Do you think its low quality cable or
the unique hinge in the Petzl headlamps putting on twisting stress.
No other brand of headlamp (I think) puts a cable to that kind of
twisting fatigue.
 
Top