I can't say since I haven't broken one yet. Been buying Surefire, Streamlight, and Energizer for about 10 years now and no accidents, no fatalities. Does it count if #1 son lost tailcap to my Energizer LED/CCFL combo?
Right now I have a black G2 (I did replace the Lexan with a Pyrex from FlashlightLens), a Microstream and a Stylus Pro, a Twin Task 2L, an Energizer WeatherReady xenon/3 led lantern, and another Energizer LED/CCFL combo light.