NiteCore EX10 Review
I give some high praises, and some very strong criticism for the NiteCore EX10.
Excellent build quality and form factor. The size of 77 mm x 21 mm makes this a light I can easily carry in a pocket, rather than a holster. So this light easily goes everywhere and anywhere. The form factor is the best CR123. I absolutely love the switch. The switch is very smooth, quiet, metal, and has an excellent feel. The switch is so smooth, you almost don't even need a momentary on/off. I find myself wanting to play with the switch all the time. Plus, the switch keeps the light shorter in length. The shape of the light doesn't have any aggressive knurls, bulges, self-gouging prongs, or other edges that will catch on clothing or make it difficult to use your pocket instead of a holster.
Runtime on high (130 lumens) is adequately 1.3 hrs on Li-ion. A maximum runtime of 60 hrs on Li-ion running at 5 lumens is more than long enough. 5 lumens is too low to me, but might be useful for someone who doesn't want to ruin their night vision. For me, I use red light if I know I'll be in that situation.
The largest complaint I have are the modes/UI. It's terrible. When in the mode of click on/off, I simply want to access my user defined brightness setting. Here's an example scenario of the frustration.
The above scenario is very frustrating. For my NiteCore Ex10, I want low and high. Once I find the low I want, I will rarely (if at all) ever change that low setting. And as for the high setting, there is little reason to require more than 130 lumens from a single CR123 battery Q5 light (I only noticed a slight difference from 130 to 215, and only noticeable at distant objects), and I can't find a reason to want less than 130 lumens on RCR123, so no need for a second memory for a high.
If I'm somehow wrong about the UI, then it is still just annoying -- being too complicated. I find it annoying to have to keep referring to the manual to learn the "tricks" to the UI. I want something simple and intuitive (more on my suggestion later).
What I liked:
What needs to be changed:
Compared with:
My perfect light:
The perfect light for me would be the form/quality/switch of the EX10 combined with the NDI UI or Fenix L1T UI.
Opinions from,
Jake
I give some high praises, and some very strong criticism for the NiteCore EX10.
Excellent build quality and form factor. The size of 77 mm x 21 mm makes this a light I can easily carry in a pocket, rather than a holster. So this light easily goes everywhere and anywhere. The form factor is the best CR123. I absolutely love the switch. The switch is very smooth, quiet, metal, and has an excellent feel. The switch is so smooth, you almost don't even need a momentary on/off. I find myself wanting to play with the switch all the time. Plus, the switch keeps the light shorter in length. The shape of the light doesn't have any aggressive knurls, bulges, self-gouging prongs, or other edges that will catch on clothing or make it difficult to use your pocket instead of a holster.
Runtime on high (130 lumens) is adequately 1.3 hrs on Li-ion. A maximum runtime of 60 hrs on Li-ion running at 5 lumens is more than long enough. 5 lumens is too low to me, but might be useful for someone who doesn't want to ruin their night vision. For me, I use red light if I know I'll be in that situation.
The largest complaint I have are the modes/UI. It's terrible. When in the mode of click on/off, I simply want to access my user defined brightness setting. Here's an example scenario of the frustration.
- I turn light on.
- Adjust light to desired output. In my case the low is too low, so I set the light to be brighter.
- The light will remember the output setting only for as long as I don't change the output setting. I can turn the light off, and when I turn the light on, it remembers my last setting. However…
- When I want to run the light on maximum output, I then lose my low setting. Memory is "replaced" by the high setting.
- I perform the mode change by double-click, and I'm back on the bottom low setting, and have to start the ramping all over again to reset my desired low. Annoying!
The above scenario is very frustrating. For my NiteCore Ex10, I want low and high. Once I find the low I want, I will rarely (if at all) ever change that low setting. And as for the high setting, there is little reason to require more than 130 lumens from a single CR123 battery Q5 light (I only noticed a slight difference from 130 to 215, and only noticeable at distant objects), and I can't find a reason to want less than 130 lumens on RCR123, so no need for a second memory for a high.
If I'm somehow wrong about the UI, then it is still just annoying -- being too complicated. I find it annoying to have to keep referring to the manual to learn the "tricks" to the UI. I want something simple and intuitive (more on my suggestion later).
What I liked:
- Build quality
- 130 lumens
- Switch
- Size/Dimensions/Form Fact
- Color
- Grip
- Pocket Clip
What needs to be changed:
- Fixed memory. This doesn't have to be complicated. It could be just like NiteCore's NDI. You have a high, and you adjust the memory for something in between low and high. Once you have selected your illumination, it remains locked and memorized. The memory cannot be changed unless you do some sort of special code or sequence. Personally, I think the memory changing mode should be initiated by X number of switch taps. Maybe 10 taps gets me into lumen change mode. Something not complicated, and something that prevents me from inadvertently changing the memory. Some sort of lockout mechanism perhaps.
- Instead of turn on, double-tap to change to low AND turn on, double-tap-hold to change to high, why not just double-tap to switch between modes?
- Get rid of the triple tap when light is turned off. Just make both mode changes a double-tap.
- Setting the lumen memory needs to be changed from the number of taps to something else. Perhaps like the NDI, but without making the flashlight longer.
- All these taps makes my mode changing unpredictable.
Compared with:
- Fenix P3D
- EagleTac P10C
My perfect light:
The perfect light for me would be the form/quality/switch of the EX10 combined with the NDI UI or Fenix L1T UI.
Opinions from,
Jake