Perhaps you should run it with SureFire SF123A batteries rather than some unsupported aftermarket batteries and see whether you notice any difference?
It's well known that RCR's have less capacity than primaries. I am sure running his L5 on RCR's is fine for the light, since the KL5A head can support up to 3 primary cells, or in other words up to 9 volts.
I was curious about the runtime quotes by Surefire as well. I thought the new version was supposed to run longer than the original LuxV version, but my luxV head ran around 45min as well with protected RCR123's. I would like to think an SSCP4 emitter producing the same lumens as a luxV would be more efficeint
From what I gather, the two different versions seem to have similar runtimes as well as output.
All that aside, I can tell you that I like the beam much better on the KL5A. It has more "punch" than the luxV version, and is still nice and smooth.....a very nice light overall