OK, here's the end of the story.
I rubbed my chin while looking at the pill and realized, I'll have to dig out the circuit board in order to reflow a new emitter. I'm not gonna do that since I don't have a spare board.
So I went to put it back together, and found that it can be turned too far. The reflector hole goes past the LED and boogers up the white (silver) material.
No biggie, I discarded the tape and went with the nude look.
I used thermal epoxy to set the LED at the best focus without a donut hole. :thumbsup:
Needless to say, I'm going to let my A2 alone. :naughty: