Hi, I'd highly recommend that you go
here fill in the checklist, copy it and edit your post #1 and paste the replies to that checklist there, this will give everyone a whole lot more required information.
Cos, e.g. 2D Mag, do a ROP (Roar of the Pelican Mod) with a high output (i think its the WA 1185 bulb) and you get output that no stock maglite can even come close to even considering the very idea of the thought of beating
BUT that isnt LED, high output, mainly spot, means no multi die LEDs, which leaves us with throwers, the DEFT comes to mind but that is outside budget, not sure how much the Tiablos are going for, the Tiablo A10 is retailing for $132 before CPF discount (code is "CPF8").
For pure throw, i'm thinking Tiablo A9 with the aspherical lens ($35 from 4 sevens before discount) but 4sevens seems to be out of stock of the A9, so you'll have to find that elsewhere.
here are some threads to help you out
2nd best thrower after DEFT
$100 - $150 thrower
do a search using the word 'thrower' in the title and loads of threads will pop up