Thanks Mr Bulk (as I continue to bask in glory for doing very little work) As far as output, let me go into a dark closet with flat white ceilings, I'll be back...
Well mine eyes can't perceive a difference at all. The 5W in the Arc is a V3 which should be similar to the L4's as I heard somewhere here, though not directly from PK hisself and certainly not under the influence of Mai Tais, that Surefire uses V flux or higher. Beamshape is the typical "star-nuclear-cross" that you get when you mate a 5W with an NX05 optic. Not nearly as smooth as using a reflector. When Arc releases the LS5 next year, I think it will raise the bar again since it will be reflectorized and will be dimmable. Can't wait.