TK21 U2/T6, EagleTac T20C2 MKII XM-L T6, or Thrunite Scorpion?

Hey guys,

I've been searching for a midsized flashlight that is very bright and these 3 have caught my interest.

First off, Fenix is coming out, or already out, with the TK21 equipped with XM-L U2 and/or T6. 468 lm OTF on max.





EagleTac T20C2 MKII XM-L T6, also fits the bill, but I'm a bit confused on the brightness. EagleTac USA claims 720 LED lm and 580 ANSI lm, but Lightjunction says 580 LED lm and 465 ANSI lm.





I think the ThruNite Scorpion looks pretty sick and falls in the same class as the 2 listed above. One website only lists the LED lm, which was 600 lm; another only lists the ANSI lm, which is 460 lm. Seems about right compared to the TK21 and ET T20C2.





I know everyone does not like it when people ask the question, "which one is better?" and it depends on the individuals preferences: UI, aesthetics, etc.

So instead of me asking the general, "which one should I get?" I will ask the question, "which one would YOU get and why?" I think this might give me some good feedback for my decision.

I ordered the Eagletac. It is the brightest of the three and most flexible with different pills available. I like the Fenix also mainly for appearance and UI. I expect to order it if it is reviewed favorably. I also like the Scorpion's UI but I will probably pass on it. I also believe it is the largest of the three which I don't personally care for.

If i had to get one i would probably go with the eagletac t20c2...i have the t20c2, klarus xt10, tk15, m21 warrior, and surefire g2x pro. I find myself always using the t20c2 for some reason.

Brightest thing in this size class is the Lumintop TD-15X, 720 lumens OTF. See selfbuilt review for details.

where does it say 720 OTF? :shrug:

and make sure to read his Issues and Observations comments.


Tod

flashflood said:

Brightest thing in this size class is the Lumintop TD-15X, 720 lumens OTF. See selfbuilt review for details.

Click to expand...

I hope, Olight will bring out the M20 in an XM-L version. And I hope, this happens soon, or I have to buy one of the above mentioned lights.

TD-15X needs 2x18650 or 3/4 x XR123 to achieve full power (650lm tested bybigchelis). With single 18650 cell Lumintop has no regulation and 500lm after 3 minutes.

It has semi-regulation, but I would go with the Thrunite Scorpion.

With the TD 15-X didn't it make a difference also if you had an old version, a later version, strobe or no strobe along with type and brand of battery?

Yeah it does, and dealers are often unclear as to which ones they have, in terms of output.

monster54 said:

Hey guys,
EagleTac T20C2 MKII XM-L T6, also fits the bill, but I'm a bit confused on the brightness. EagleTac USA claims 720 LED lm and 580 ANSI lm, but Lightjunction says 580 LED lm and 465 ANSI lm.

Click to expand...

There are two different ones. The first one that came out a few months ago, and the new one that just came out this week. The first T20C2 XM-L was XM-L T6 COOL LOP - 550 Lumen for maximum output with approx. 15% less throw than XP-G R5. (Runtimes are same as XP-G R5). The new one just released is XM-L T6 High Output COOL LOP - 720 Lumen/580 ANSI Lumen.

FYI, the new one only has 720 LED lumens for 3 minutes, and then steps down.

but switch light off/on every 3 min and you'll have the boosted TURBO 720 lumen/580 ANSI for over an hour... :devil:
(EDIT: depending on battery power)

Tod

offthetrail said:

...
FYI, the new one only has 720 LED lumens for 3 minutes, and then steps down.

Click to expand...

lebox97 said:

but switch light off/on every 3 min and you'll have the boosted TURBO 720 lumen/580 ANSI for over an hour... :devil:

Tod

Click to expand...

I plan to, as I just received my new module... Thanks for the quick shipment.

I am waiting for Zebralights 1x18650/XM-L light to come out before I make a decision on this form factor. I think it will be out this month. SC600?

lebox97 said:

but switch light off/on every 3 min and you'll have the boosted TURBO 720 lumen/580 ANSI for over an hour... :devil:
(EDIT: depending on battery power)

Tod

Click to expand...

That isn't how it works.

Switching it off/on will not get rid of all the heat that built up, thus reducing the emitters efficiency and output

offthetrail said:

There are two different ones. The first one that came out a few months ago, and the new one that just came out this week. The first T20C2 XM-L was XM-L T6 COOL LOP - 550 Lumen for maximum output with approx. 15% less throw than XP-G R5. (Runtimes are same as XP-G R5). The new one just released is XM-L T6 High Output COOL LOP - 720 Lumen/580 ANSI Lumen.

FYI, the new one only has 720 LED lumens for 3 minutes, and then steps down.

Click to expand...

the new one has the so called C2100 chip. It was just released 3-4 days ago..at least as far as the announcement letter to distributors

skullony said:

If i had to get one i would probably go with the eagletac t20c2...i have the t20c2, klarus xt10, tk15, m21 warrior, and surefire g2x pro. I find myself always using the t20c2 for some reason.

Click to expand...

How much brighter is the t20c2 xm-l to the klarus xt10??

I think the X10 is about 450-470 lumens or so and I think slightly little more of a floodlight than the T20C2. I think the UI of the XT10 looks better than it is in reality, but still a nice light.

pageyjim said:

I think the X10 is about 450-470 lumens or so and I think slightly little more of a floodlight than the T20C2. I think the UI of the XT10 looks better than it is in reality, but still a nice light.

Click to expand...

I have the t20c2 xm-l now. I'm just trying to decide between the xt10 and the td15x. And I wanted to know how much brighter the xt10 than the t20c2 cause that's kinda clode to the td15.

The TD 15X is brighter than the XT10. I think the TD15X is like 600 OTF lumens. I have almost purchased the TD15X about 5 times too lol. Not important to most people but the XT10 does not fit into their holster very well with the cigar grip installed.