The Maglites going to be brighter and more reliable. The Noma is giving you an emitter lumens reading (at best)
I have a couple at the cabin (were the ones that work but I hardly use go)
Noma may be 60-90 lumens do to the plastic lens and reflector. Makes for a sturdy little light.
Maglite 3watt should be 110+ lumens otf. Sturdy, and focusable. Even the Maglite XL50 which is in the same size and battery class as the Noma will make a much better light than the Noma