Re: Rayovac Roughneck
I bought a Rayovac Roughneck RNR2D last year for my evening trail-walk, it had a rubber-cushioned headpiece and tailpiece, seemed sturdy, and had good output and beam. Getting out of my car one night, I dropped it on its tailpiece, cracking the plastic and rendering it inoperative. I removed the (useless) rubber cushion, and duct-taped the tailpiece parts together, restoring its operation for a few weeks, but it eventually fell apart under very light (twice per week) use.
I replaced it with an Energizer Industrial 2D LED (IN2DLEDM) with not as good (but adequate) output and beam, and eventually dropped it by accident exactly as I had done with the Roughneck, stepping out of the same car, in the same parking lot. No damage, no diminution of light output, no nothing.
My one-sample conclusion is that the Roughneck is not "rough" at all, and the Energizer is much better for the purpose.