:welcome: shutterdial & JudasD
I did not get either.
I live downtown. Do not take walks down long country roads. Do not go camping. No need for super bright torches.
I already have a 3C P7 Mag. While not as bright as either it is bright enough for a shelf queen. Last time I used it was walking some trails in High Park Toronto with some GTA members over 2 years ago.
I found out at the get together the year before that neutral tinted lights do not cast a blue haze on vegetation like normal LEDs. The brightest lights use the coolest tints which does not render colours as well as neutrals. Not critical indoors or downtown but in the country with lots of vegetation.
Some cool, neutral and warm tint comparisons:
http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb...arm-Neutral-Cool-White-BEAMSHOTS-amp-RUNTIMES!
http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb...ion-and-Tint-Comparison-Cree-Rebel-GDP-Nichia
http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb...lights-do-you-love-em-If-not-take-a-look-here!
http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb...w-comparison-Lumintop-TD-15X-T5-neutral-white
If I was starting over I would probably go with a Jetbeam PA20, Fenix LD40 or Neutral-white Quark "X" AA² Tactical.
The Neutral-white Quark "X" AA² Tactical is only 260 lumens* but is bright enough. When I point it at the ceiling and turn it on (in Turbo) it feels like I have turned on a household bulb, not a flashlight.
It will fit in the back pocket of my jeans which a TK41 (2D Mag size) or a TK70 (4D Mag size) does not. (A light with you is worth 2 in a drawer.)
It is very floody, does not reach far. For shorter distances that is more useful but if you need to reach out look for something else.
* The TK41 is 800 lumens about the same as a 60W bulb, the TK70 is 2200 lumens 1.5X a 100W bulb.
EDIT
BTW if you get the TK70 you need NiMH for full brightness. Alkaline will not power the torch properly. 4 10,000 mAH LSD or 12,000 mHA D NiMH plus charger will cost you.
The TK41 will run with 8 alkalines or 8 or 4 NiMH.