AKU review----How do you choose a good EDC flashlight

aku1979

Banned
Joined
Feb 22, 2012
Messages
2
Hello everyone!

Here is AKU review.

Today, I am going to compare with EDC flashlights.

For me, EDC light don't have to super bright, can be use for walk is enough.

Stable quality, long runtime, have moonlight mode in case of emergency. And in right size.


So I choose some of my EDC lights that I think are really suitable for every day carry.


Participant lights:

18650 lights: Spark-SL6S, ThruNite TN12, SKILHUNT Ideal-C2, Pioneer S32

CR123 lights: Jetbeam PC20, Surefire E1B, Xtar WK21, Nitecore EX11XP

AA lights: Nitecore D11V2.5, Eoslamp SMA12
DPP_0340.jpg


Pics:

Spark-SL6S-800CW
DPP_0305.jpg

DPP_0302.jpg

DPP_0300.jpg
DPP_0296.jpg

SKILHUNT Ideal-C2
DPP_0176.jpg

DPP_0175.jpg

Pioneer S32
DPP_0143.jpg

DPP_0140.jpg

DPP_0138.jpg

ThruNite TN12

64455587201201080001245448162741167_006.jpg
64455587201201071738392449004628103_001.jpg

Jetbeam PC20
IMG_3642.jpg
IMG_3635.jpg
IMG_3631.jpg

Xtar WK21
DPP_0318.jpg
DPP_0316.jpg

Surefire E1B

DPP_0314.jpg

Group Photo of participants

18650 lights group photo:
DPP_0307.jpg

CR123 lights group photo:
DPP_0309.jpg

AA lights group photo:
DPP_0310.jpg


Beamshot:

18650 lights group:(Lift-to-right) Spark-SL6S, ThruNite TN12, Pioneer S32,SKILHUNT Ideal-C2
DPP_0319_B8B1B1BE.jpg

CR123 lights group:(Lift-to-right) Jetbeam PC20, Surefire E1B, Xtar WK21, Nitecore EX11XP
DPP_0323_B8B1B1BE.jpg

AA lights groupNitecore (Lift-to-right) D11V2.5, Eoslamp SMA12
DPP_0327_B8B1B1BE.jpg


80X80 Studio flood light:

18650 lights group: (Lift-to-right) Spark-SL6S, ThruNite TN12, SKILHUNT Ideal-C2, Pioneer S32
DPP_0342_B8B1B1BE.jpg

CR123 lights group:(Lift-to-right) Jetbeam PC20, Surefire E1B, Xtar WK21, Nitecore EX11XP
DPP_0346_B8B1B1BE.jpg

AA lights group(Lift-to-right) Nitecore D11V2.5, Eoslamp SMA12
DPP_0350_B8B1B1BE.jpg


Indoor 8 meters:

18650 lights group:(Lift-to-right) Spark-SL6S, ThruNite TN12, Pioneer S32,SKILHUNT Ideal-C2,
DPP_0329_B8B1B1BE.jpg

Spark-SL6S-800CW: High mode is too hot to use if long time lighting.

ThruNite TN12:
Temperature control circuit, sound fashion.
SKILHUNT Ideal-C2: 320Lumens, nice output for longtime us. Nice design, compact size and light weight, suitable for EDC

Pioneer S32: High mode is too hot to use if long time lighting. Good workmanship, multi mode


CR123 lights group: (Lift-to-right) Jetbeam PC20, Surefire E1B, Xtar WK21, Nitecore EX11XP

DPP_0333_B8B1B1BE.jpg

Jetbeam PC20: Good workmanship, nice output for longtime use

Xtar WK21: multi mode, too hot if use long time, super flood light, short runtime.

Surefire E1B: 120Lumens, totally thrower, no flood, too throw for walk.

Nitecore EX11XP: Work good both flood and throw. But R5 led, Alloy switch,
Infinitely Variable digitally controlled brightness.

AA lights group(Lift-to-right) Nitecore D11V2.5, Eoslamp SMA12
DPP_0337_B8B1B1BE.jpg

Nitecore D11V2.5: Better to use 14500 Li battery. Weak R5 LED.

Eoslamp SMA12: Good runtime, output and heat dissipation, But price too high and accessories quality looks not good.


Outdoor 50 meters:
DPP_0352_B8B1B1BE.jpg

18650 lights group (Lift-to-right) Spark-SL6S, ThruNite TN12, SKILHUNT Ideal-C2, Pioneer S32
DPP_0354_B8B1B1BE.jpg

CR123 lights group: (Lift-to-right) Jetbeam PC20, Surefire E1B, Xtar WK21, Nitecore EX11XP
DPP_0358_B8B1B1BE.jpg


AA lights group (Lift-to-right) Nitecore D11V2.5, Eoslamp SMA12


DPP_0362_B8B1B1BE.jpg
Outdoor 100 meters:

18650 lights group (Lift-to-right) Spark-SL6S, ThruNite TN12, SKILHUNT Ideal-C2, Pioneer S32
DPP_0364_B8B1B1BE.jpg

CR123 lights group: (Lift-to-right) Jetbeam PC20, Surefire E1B, Xtar WK21, Nitecore EX11XP


DPP_0368_B8B1B1BE.jpg
AA lights group (Lift-to-right) Nitecore D11V2.5, Eoslamp SMA12


IMG_4801_B8B1B1BE.jpg
Final comments:

18650 lights group:

Spark-SL6S-800CW: High price, Nice workmanship, High mode is too hot to use if long time lighting. Not suitable for EDC.

ThruNite TN12:
Moderate price, High mode use is hot but have temperature control circuit, it's ok to EDC.
SKILHUNT Ideal-C2: Low price, nice brightness, long runtime, compact size and light weight, suitable for EDC (suggest)

Pioneer S32: High mode is too hot to use if long time lighting. Better quality in the Chinese DIY brands.


CR123 lights group:

Jetbeam PC20:
Moderate price, good workmanship, body is a little slim. Nice brightness and runtime, suitable for EDC (suggest)
Xtar WK21: Low price, moderate workmanship, compact size, magnet tail, DIY mode, suitable for EDC.

Surefire E1B: Costly price, moderate workmanship, compact size, totally thrower, no flood, ok to EDC.

Nitecore EX11XP:
Moderate price, weak R5 led, no clip, alloy switch (feels very bad). Innovate "Infinitely Variable" digitally controlled brightness. Suitable for EDC

AA lights group

Nitecore D11V2.5: 1.5V AA battery is
ungeliable. Better to use 3.7V 14500 Li battery. Alloy switch (feels very bad). Nice brightness and runtime, suitable for EDC.
Eoslamp SMA12: Too high price( A DIY brand price even higher than famous brand.), workmanship in detail is not good enough. Suitable for EDC.


Thank you for watching!

English is not my native language, if presented any mistake, please let me know, I will appreciate that. thanks.
 
Last edited:

niteye001

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Dec 11, 2011
Messages
7
very good review, so many EDC flashlight and so much "米",nice pictuer.:hitit:
 

fishndad

Enlightened
Joined
Apr 28, 2012
Messages
460
Location
ohio
sorry but some of my edc lights are only 2 weeks old and they are significantly more worn than anyone of those lights.
whitch one of those ltghts have you EDCed? How do you keep them prestine?
 
Top