Hi Tyler. I admit there are far more people here who can advise as I am limited in my collection but I did buy a Fenix TK50. Thing I liked about it was the large reflector, side switches and the fact it used standard D cell batteries. On the heavy side but a robust light with heaps of throw and a bit of side flood coverage (small) and a good price. Oh and the run times are very good. I have not looked up the two options you are looking at but I would stay clear of lights who have special manufactures batteries. May not be an issue if you are always at base and getting the battery (preferably removable battery) recharged but the great thing with standard batteries like AAA,AA,C and D is they are available anywhere. You could also get rechargeable batteries of the same type. Also multi LED lights even though they advertise high lumens does not necessarily mean you are going to get the throw you want. A single LED light with the right reflector, circuit and power source will outdo a multi LED light due to its design (generalization).i would suggest you go to goinggear.com and look at Marshall doing his light tests outside and you will see how good or not so good some of the lights are in the real world.