rlichter
Newly Enlightened
A couple of years ago I decided to buy a headlamp for reading in bed and purchased a Spark ST5-220CW. The high parasitic drain of the electronic switch should have disqualified this iteration of the headlamp from sale to the public, but that's a quality control and ethics issue (apparently improved in subsequent runs). What I want to mention is the "CW" in the model number, which stands for "Cool White". In fact there's very little white, cool or otherwise, about it: it's quite green, not just greenish in the corona like my Clicky 170, but green throughout the beam pattern. Fine, if you like green LED lights. Not so fine if you don't. Green possibly has a better CRI than the bluish-white I favor, but CRI isn't everything.
I take night walks six or seven times a week, lots of hills and trees and deer and racoons and owls around here, and I thought I'd like to experience what it's like with a headlamp. The ST5 is okay for closeup work but it's not bright enough for distant viewing and you won't get all that much run time from an AA alkaline. So I bought an ST6-500CW using an XM-L2 U2 and the redoubtable 18650 primary. This one looked mostly white in the video. And I have flashlights using the XM-L U2, XM-L U3 and XM-L2 U2. They all have some green in the beam pattern, but at any reasonable distance really appear cool white. The ST6 arrived yesterday and, you guessed it, once again "Cool White" turns out to be a euphemism for "Saturated Green". Much greener, in fact, than my ST5. Color in YouTube videos can be deceptive, but I had three XM-L lights that didn't have the green problem. What gives?
I called the dealer and he said the green has to do with the shallowness of the reflector. This doesn't explain why a greenish light is called cool white, of course. I'm don't know how LEDs are manufactured, how the phosphor is applied, but I can kind of get how the reflector angle might play a role in beam pattern color. I invite comments, and suggestions for a high quality headlamp that is actually cool white, takes an 18650 and has decent throw.
I take night walks six or seven times a week, lots of hills and trees and deer and racoons and owls around here, and I thought I'd like to experience what it's like with a headlamp. The ST5 is okay for closeup work but it's not bright enough for distant viewing and you won't get all that much run time from an AA alkaline. So I bought an ST6-500CW using an XM-L2 U2 and the redoubtable 18650 primary. This one looked mostly white in the video. And I have flashlights using the XM-L U2, XM-L U3 and XM-L2 U2. They all have some green in the beam pattern, but at any reasonable distance really appear cool white. The ST6 arrived yesterday and, you guessed it, once again "Cool White" turns out to be a euphemism for "Saturated Green". Much greener, in fact, than my ST5. Color in YouTube videos can be deceptive, but I had three XM-L lights that didn't have the green problem. What gives?
I called the dealer and he said the green has to do with the shallowness of the reflector. This doesn't explain why a greenish light is called cool white, of course. I'm don't know how LEDs are manufactured, how the phosphor is applied, but I can kind of get how the reflector angle might play a role in beam pattern color. I invite comments, and suggestions for a high quality headlamp that is actually cool white, takes an 18650 and has decent throw.