Some lights do it walking. I'm talking about walking lights. The criteria for walking lights are different than for an EDC light. There is a lot of overlap and a few of the lights I want to look at are common EDC lights.
A superior beam is what makes a good walking light. Followed by tint and based on your preferences. Size and extended runtimes are less important. I grab a light before going for a walk and I don't need extended runtimes. One other thing that I need is multiple modes. This makes the walking light much more useful.
I've picked 6 lights to look at: Moddoolar H3 Nichia 219 Triple, Malkoff M361 N, McGizmo Haiku, HDS 200 Clickie, L3 Illumination L10 and Dereelight DA3. The L10 and DA3 are running on AA and AAA Eneloops and were on H mode. The other lights were on M modes.
Up against the wall.
The Oveready puts out a wall of light. This is M (1-cell) and there is a lot of light. Very useful on L. No moon mode, but L is fine.
The Malkoff has a hot spot with good spill Nice tint.
The Haiku has a wonderful beam. The tint is cool white without any blue.
The HDS is a little more throwy. The multiple modes are very useful.
The L10 has a nice floody beam and the Nichia 219 also provides a nice tint and hi cri.
The DA3 has a vey broad beam for an AAA. The greenish tint is not meant for white wall hunting.
More realistic use.
The Oveready puts out a lot of white, hi cri light. This is M in a 1-cell set up.
The Malkoff is a hot spot with a lot of spill. The eye handles the spill better than the camera.
I have checked this and the Haiku may not have been aimed correctly. Seems to be aimed a little to the left. Plenty of light and good spill - just as the white wall hunting showed. Like the Malkoff, the eye does a better job using the spill than the camera captures. I consider this the most useful beam for walking.
I checked this and the HDS is more throwy than the other lights. Still very useful, especially with the easily accessible multiple modes. Not to mention that some users prefer a light with more throw.
The L10 puts out a lot of light on an Eneloop on H. L and M are useful in real life.
No problem with the greenish tint in real life. This H on an Eneloop. Lots of light in a very broad and useful beam. L or M will work fine for most uses.
I had a few surprises. The usefulness of multiple modes was clear and the more modes the better - as long as the modes are easily accessible. The HDS 200 was more throwy than I thought. The beams from the smaller AA and AAA lights were better than I thought they would be. They are viable options with Eneloops with occasional use on H.
What other lights are good walking lights? What other features do you think are important to consider? I picked 6 lights to look at and I hope that doesn't end the discussion. There are other good lights for walking - what do you use and like?