How to compare Wh of various batteries?

rickypanecatyl

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 2, 2009
Messages
913
I wanted to get myself a bit more familiar with how different batteries stack up (18650 Li-ion vs AAA NiMH) against each other in terms of total capacity & capacity for size/weight but realized I'm a bit fuzzy on the numbers.

I know Amps * Volts = Watts, so I'm assuming that Amp Hours * Volts = Watt hours/Wh? Is this correct?

I've got a Eagletac battery sitting in front of me that says 3500mAh & 13Wh on the packaging; So that is just 3.5Ah*3.7V correct? If so, I was just wondering why 3.7volts vs 4.2Volts?

Looking at Energizer's spec sheet for their AAA pre-charged NiMH it's rated .7Ah. To get Wh do I multiply that by 1.5Volts or Nominal 1.2Volts? If 1.2 that would be .84Wh. Are there other factors that significantly change the bottom line Wh?


I was also curious how different batteries compare in total capacity for their size and weight. For example the 2 batteries I've already mentioned:

Energizer AAA pre-charged lists - 11 grams and 3.8cm cubed. For my Eagletac 18650 I'm just roughly guessing the volume at 16.5cm cubed (I didn't measure - just assumed 18mm diameter/.9cm radius and 6.5mm length or .9 squared*3.14*6.5) and I did weigh it and found it to be 49 grams. So does this chart look right to compare Wh for size/weight?


BatteryWatt HourVolumeWeightWh/CM3​Wh/gram
ET 18650 Li-ion13Wh16.5cm3​49 grams.84.27
Egzr AAA 700.84Wh3.8cm3​11 grams.22.08

So roughly could I conclude in this case the 18650 Li-ion has 3.8x as much capacity for it's size and 3.4x as much capacity for its weight?

Are there any charts out there already that compare this kind of info? I couldn't find Energizers numbers for Wh or Eagletac's for volume/weight...
 

HKJ

Flashaholic
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
9,715
Location
Copenhagen, Denmark
For Alkaline batteries the energy varies significantly with load current.
You best way to get comparable Wh values is my reviews, there is a box at the top of each review that contains Wh for different loads.
 

grayjay70

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Dec 12, 2018
Messages
31
Calculate the watt-hours at the nominal voltage which is close to the average voltage the battery can provide over its useful capacity. A battery is able to produce more watts when it is fully charged but that max power output potential drops as the battery is discharged.

For both size and weight comparison, a useful graph with a good visual comparison titled; Relative Energy Density of Some Common Secondary Cell Chemistries
can be found near bottom of page https://www.mpoweruk.com/chemistries.htm




 

xxo

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 30, 2015
Messages
3,008
For Alkaline batteries the energy varies significantly with load current.
You best way to get comparable Wh values is my reviews, there is a box at the top of each review that contains Wh for different loads.

+ 1 - HKJ's reviews are the best resource on the web for this, he has Wh listed at the various loads for all of the batteries he has tested.
 
Top