js
Flashlight Enthusiast
There are two main ways in which lamps are held in place relative to reflectors. They are either held with a socket and pedestal assembly, such as with the MagLite's, or they are potted directly into the bore of the reflector, such as with StreamLight's 20X and 35X, and TigerLight's Gold System lights. SureFire P60, P61, P90 and P91 lamp assemblies are essentially the same as this second method, because the lamp and reflector form a single unit.
The socket and pedestal assembly allows for flexibility in focusing the tightness of the beam and does not necessitate throwing away the reflector along with a burnt out lamp. However, the filament is often not centered above the center of the socket to such a degree as to introduce serious beam artifacts. Bending the pins of a bi-pin lamp can sometimes fix this problem, but not always. In addition, the heat and IR radiation from the lamp can be a problem for many sockets, causing them to melt and deform.
The lamp/reflector assembly—where the lamp is fixed in place in the reflector via a potting compound or ceramic discs and springs—does not allow for any focusing of the beam and requires that the entire assembly be replaced anytime the lamp fails. However, one can almost always count on a decently centered hot spot and a beam with no serious aberrations or artifacts, as well as a high degree of heat resistance and shielding due to the ceramic material or potting compound.
From the point of view of the flashlight modder, potting lamps into reflectors is an unmitigated nightmare. There are three axis positions (x,y,z) and one angle (filament angle) to get right, and this simply cannot be done by eye. A jig is required to power up the light in the reflector, adjust the relative positions until a good beam is achieved, and then hold the lamp and reflector while the potting compound is injected and cured.
In the process of muddling my way through my TigerLight modding project, I was driven by several necessities to a sort of hybrid method which I believe has some small degree of interest for home flashlight-modders such as frequent CPF. I call it "fixture-ring lamp potting" or "ring-potting" for short. I highly doubt that this idea is original or remarkable from a professional's point of view, but I have not seen anything like it detailed on CPF and so I am detailing it here in case anyone would like to use it, or is interested in how I am putting together my lamps and reflectors for the TigerLight Upgrades.
The idea is simple: a Carley RF1940 2" reflector has a .377" bore with a set screw for securing a lamp in the reflector. ( Carley sells metal sleeves which somehow fit over the lamp, but the sleeves they have will not fit Welch Allyn lamps, and this idea has never appealed to me due to the danger of a short circuit across the lamp pins and the danger of cracking the glass capsule due to pressure from the set-screw. ) This allows the potting process to be broken down into two separate steps by first potting the lamp into a .375" cylindrical ring (3/8") and then sliding the ring up into the bore until the proper focal length is obtained. At this point the set screw is tightened to secure the ring-potted lamp in position. Thus a person can visually center the filament in the ring, pot it, and then move the ring in and out to get the desired focus and beam.
Thus, the immediate questions become "what do I use for fixture-rings?", "what compound do I use for potting?", and "how do I hold the potting compound from leaking out the bottom of the ring while potting the lamp into place?"
I use sections cut from a 3/8" o.d. stainless steel tube, with a wall thickness of .028. Unfortunately, many nominal 3/8" o.d. tubes are slightly larger than .375" and will NOT fit up through the bore of a 1940, but with some persistance a suitable length of tube can probably be found. The rings must be cut with an abrasive cut-off wheel in order to avoid deforming them and leaving overly large cusps on the edges.
For a potting compound, I am using Cotronics 940LE ceramic adhesive/potting compound. Anyone can buy from Cotronics, but the smallest size is a pint (for $65 or so) and it needs to be mixed by weight. A scale accurate to .1 gram is needed.
I cover the bottom of the hole with the blue, removeable masking tape, and then poke the lamp wires through the tape. I first make sure that the wires are straight and even, and then hold the ring up to the light so that I can see the positions of the wires when I hold them to the tape. That way I can ensure that they are centered before I poke them through the tape.
Below is a picture of two empty rings, and one ring covered with tape, with a WA lamp poking through. Notice that the rings have a hole drilled through one side and partially through the opposite wall. I had to start doing this in order to preclude the possibility of the potting and lamp coming lose from the ring with repeated thermal cycling and insertion and removal from reflectors.
I have also found it necessary to fashion some sort of jig to hold the lamp and ring during the potting process. I drilled holes in a piece of aluminum bar stock, and then drilled out shoulders in the holes, so that the rings with tape fit snugly in the bar and bottom out when the hole narrows, and so that the pins of the lamp poke down into the narrow section and are held above the table due to the thickness of the aluminum. My rings are .260 or so deep and I find that if they sink less than half way into the aluminum that this is ideal. I used 1/2" thick and 2" wide stock, holes 2" apart on center, with an inch clearance at the ends. A picture of one of these jigs appears below:
Notice that the lamps are pulled up high and are leaning out of the way. This allows for easier delivery of the potting compound. I apply the potting with a disposeable plasitc syringe. Note that you can carefully push the lamp down into the potting, and then pull it up again to add more compound if needed. The potting is quite paste like and will not leak past the lamp pins, but the pins must NOT leave the holes in the tape!
I have found that it is much easier to accurately center the filaments if you use a 1940 to help you. I carefully place the reflector down over the half of the ring that sticks up above the bar, and move the lamp around with a Q-tip until the filament is centered. DO NOT TOUCH THE LAMP GLASS during the potting process, as it could cause the lamp to explode or leak during running. Cleaning after the fact will not necessarily help as the portion of the lamp glass that is below the top of the ring but above the potting will be inaccessible. I clean the lamps thoroughly with isopropyl alcohol before I start--just to be safe--and then use a cloth or Q-tips from then on.
I go through a few round of placing the reflector over a lamp and adjusting it and moving on to the next one, until I am certain that everything is positioned correctly. Next I put the jig in the oven at 200F for 15 minutes, remove and let cool, then take off the tape and file off any bit of potting that got on the pins and outside of the ring. here are two finished ring-potted lamps:
Notice the red dot on the back of one of them. That indicates a WA 1185 lamp. I find this to be a good way of marking the ring-potted lamps, as they will all look very much alike otherwise.
Again, avoid touching the glass, but if you do it is not critical at this point. Simply clean with isopropyl alcohol before use.
And finally, slide the ring-potted lamp up into the bore of the reflector to a likely position and snug down the set screw. There is no need to tighten the set screw very much--ever. Now attach the lamp lead wires, loosen the set screw, turn on the light, and move the ring-potted lamp in and out to obtain the best beam and re-tighten the set screw. Here is what you end up with:
And that's all I can think of at the moment. I can sell a small amount of the Cotronics 940LE to interested CPFers. PM if you're interested.
The socket and pedestal assembly allows for flexibility in focusing the tightness of the beam and does not necessitate throwing away the reflector along with a burnt out lamp. However, the filament is often not centered above the center of the socket to such a degree as to introduce serious beam artifacts. Bending the pins of a bi-pin lamp can sometimes fix this problem, but not always. In addition, the heat and IR radiation from the lamp can be a problem for many sockets, causing them to melt and deform.
The lamp/reflector assembly—where the lamp is fixed in place in the reflector via a potting compound or ceramic discs and springs—does not allow for any focusing of the beam and requires that the entire assembly be replaced anytime the lamp fails. However, one can almost always count on a decently centered hot spot and a beam with no serious aberrations or artifacts, as well as a high degree of heat resistance and shielding due to the ceramic material or potting compound.
From the point of view of the flashlight modder, potting lamps into reflectors is an unmitigated nightmare. There are three axis positions (x,y,z) and one angle (filament angle) to get right, and this simply cannot be done by eye. A jig is required to power up the light in the reflector, adjust the relative positions until a good beam is achieved, and then hold the lamp and reflector while the potting compound is injected and cured.
In the process of muddling my way through my TigerLight modding project, I was driven by several necessities to a sort of hybrid method which I believe has some small degree of interest for home flashlight-modders such as frequent CPF. I call it "fixture-ring lamp potting" or "ring-potting" for short. I highly doubt that this idea is original or remarkable from a professional's point of view, but I have not seen anything like it detailed on CPF and so I am detailing it here in case anyone would like to use it, or is interested in how I am putting together my lamps and reflectors for the TigerLight Upgrades.
The idea is simple: a Carley RF1940 2" reflector has a .377" bore with a set screw for securing a lamp in the reflector. ( Carley sells metal sleeves which somehow fit over the lamp, but the sleeves they have will not fit Welch Allyn lamps, and this idea has never appealed to me due to the danger of a short circuit across the lamp pins and the danger of cracking the glass capsule due to pressure from the set-screw. ) This allows the potting process to be broken down into two separate steps by first potting the lamp into a .375" cylindrical ring (3/8") and then sliding the ring up into the bore until the proper focal length is obtained. At this point the set screw is tightened to secure the ring-potted lamp in position. Thus a person can visually center the filament in the ring, pot it, and then move the ring in and out to get the desired focus and beam.
Thus, the immediate questions become "what do I use for fixture-rings?", "what compound do I use for potting?", and "how do I hold the potting compound from leaking out the bottom of the ring while potting the lamp into place?"
I use sections cut from a 3/8" o.d. stainless steel tube, with a wall thickness of .028. Unfortunately, many nominal 3/8" o.d. tubes are slightly larger than .375" and will NOT fit up through the bore of a 1940, but with some persistance a suitable length of tube can probably be found. The rings must be cut with an abrasive cut-off wheel in order to avoid deforming them and leaving overly large cusps on the edges.
For a potting compound, I am using Cotronics 940LE ceramic adhesive/potting compound. Anyone can buy from Cotronics, but the smallest size is a pint (for $65 or so) and it needs to be mixed by weight. A scale accurate to .1 gram is needed.
I cover the bottom of the hole with the blue, removeable masking tape, and then poke the lamp wires through the tape. I first make sure that the wires are straight and even, and then hold the ring up to the light so that I can see the positions of the wires when I hold them to the tape. That way I can ensure that they are centered before I poke them through the tape.
Below is a picture of two empty rings, and one ring covered with tape, with a WA lamp poking through. Notice that the rings have a hole drilled through one side and partially through the opposite wall. I had to start doing this in order to preclude the possibility of the potting and lamp coming lose from the ring with repeated thermal cycling and insertion and removal from reflectors.
I have also found it necessary to fashion some sort of jig to hold the lamp and ring during the potting process. I drilled holes in a piece of aluminum bar stock, and then drilled out shoulders in the holes, so that the rings with tape fit snugly in the bar and bottom out when the hole narrows, and so that the pins of the lamp poke down into the narrow section and are held above the table due to the thickness of the aluminum. My rings are .260 or so deep and I find that if they sink less than half way into the aluminum that this is ideal. I used 1/2" thick and 2" wide stock, holes 2" apart on center, with an inch clearance at the ends. A picture of one of these jigs appears below:
Notice that the lamps are pulled up high and are leaning out of the way. This allows for easier delivery of the potting compound. I apply the potting with a disposeable plasitc syringe. Note that you can carefully push the lamp down into the potting, and then pull it up again to add more compound if needed. The potting is quite paste like and will not leak past the lamp pins, but the pins must NOT leave the holes in the tape!
I have found that it is much easier to accurately center the filaments if you use a 1940 to help you. I carefully place the reflector down over the half of the ring that sticks up above the bar, and move the lamp around with a Q-tip until the filament is centered. DO NOT TOUCH THE LAMP GLASS during the potting process, as it could cause the lamp to explode or leak during running. Cleaning after the fact will not necessarily help as the portion of the lamp glass that is below the top of the ring but above the potting will be inaccessible. I clean the lamps thoroughly with isopropyl alcohol before I start--just to be safe--and then use a cloth or Q-tips from then on.
I go through a few round of placing the reflector over a lamp and adjusting it and moving on to the next one, until I am certain that everything is positioned correctly. Next I put the jig in the oven at 200F for 15 minutes, remove and let cool, then take off the tape and file off any bit of potting that got on the pins and outside of the ring. here are two finished ring-potted lamps:
Notice the red dot on the back of one of them. That indicates a WA 1185 lamp. I find this to be a good way of marking the ring-potted lamps, as they will all look very much alike otherwise.
Again, avoid touching the glass, but if you do it is not critical at this point. Simply clean with isopropyl alcohol before use.
And finally, slide the ring-potted lamp up into the bore of the reflector to a likely position and snug down the set screw. There is no need to tighten the set screw very much--ever. Now attach the lamp lead wires, loosen the set screw, turn on the light, and move the ring-potted lamp in and out to obtain the best beam and re-tighten the set screw. Here is what you end up with:
And that's all I can think of at the moment. I can sell a small amount of the Cotronics 940LE to interested CPFers. PM if you're interested.
Last edited: