Well, the 1W looks nice, just like Quickbeam's review:
Dorcy Lux review
It's smaller than you would think from the pictures (but see Quickbeam's comparo with Mag), and darker than in the pictures.
It was in the regular flashlight section at Target. The ones I went to (in NJ and NY) were both low on Dorcy's, and almost sold out of crappy Energizer 2Ds. People must be stocking up on them for some reason, hurricane? school? camping?
THe Dorcy was $24.99, which isn't terrible at all, but a few things make me hesitate.
First, it's 3AAA, so there must be a plastic carrier to hold the batteries. That makes it harder to reload, and easier to lose a piece of it, a piece than can fall out. Also, it's thick, though short, so would make a nice general at home light, but I'd never EDC it, when I could bring the VIP or Blackbird, or an Arc... And, as I mentioned earlier, I'm quite happy with the SL Jr, even though that lite is too long, it has a nice small diameter.
And, BTW, I did bring the Dorcy 2C to the scanner, and it still came up $19.58. I guess the Target gods didn't want me to buy it!
daloosh