Oh, I prefer flood beams so I am not worried about throw. My Pelican M6 LED has plenty of throw (I was able to light up deer on the hill while hiking at night, probably 50 yards away), and the beam is perfect out of the box--one of the few lights other than Surefires or the Arc 4 that comes with IMO a perfect beam. I don't think I'll need more throw than the PM6 LED gives me, since my majority of my light uses are close quarters indoors or for medium range outside. If I absolutely ever do need 100-200 yard potential, I suppose I can save one 4D Maglite and NOT mod with the diffuser, but I doubt I'll ever need that range. Besides, even my stock (unmodded) Elektrolumens FT-3C gives me some serious throw, about 75-100 yards when the batteries are at full power. So, I do have options if I need medium to medium-long range throw. Its only the 100 plus yard (long) throw that I don't have many options for, except for maybe my 4D Maglites, but I doubt I'll ever need that kind of throw anyway.
For my Maglites that have crappy out of the box beam, I'd happily sacrifice many throw for beam quality. I absolutely HATE the artifact driven beams my C and D cell Maglites have. A close to medium range flood of light would be much appreciated, and I think if I add the EverLED it will give me more battery life and greater output (especially in the 2D/2C models)? I notice also that a smoother flood beam is easier on my eyes in close quarters than an uneven spot, so I think I might liking this mod.
I did try the acrylic spray on the reflector once, and I ruined a reflector and produced a worst beam. I clearly am not good at painting or spraying that stuff on, because most people that try to do that mod report excellent results.