ag4gt,
since you have an older decrepit MC, it is quite likely the reason(s) for the light not working are corroded and/or oxidized electrical contact surfaces/points. Yeah, somebody ought to do a tutorial with pictures for cleaning these M*g switch assemblies /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif...me I just post 'useless' posts. The new M*gChr switch assembly I ordered may not be exactly the same as yours, some M*g switch assemblies/parts have changed slightly in design over the years.
I'm working on such a tutorial, but not sure it will get done in time for most (too late for some who could have used this information last week, or the week before)...seems like there is an onslaught of these bad/oxidized contacts problems popping up just now????
If you like I could provide a link for buying a new switch assembly in California, but it costs $10.50 plus UPS shipping, which ran me $6+, and I live just 40 miles from that place that has a good stock of these replacement switch assemblies (link is in another thread, which some haven't yet looked for). Note, what we refer to as switch 'assembly'; in contrast to that actual switch, which is the small plastic piece with the 'clicky' button for on/off. That part easily splits into two pieces, but you have to be careful not to break off the two thin mounting studs on one half the the plastic switch. Inside there are contacts that you can clean up with suitable tools...I have a special 'tool' I use to clean up contacts /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif. But you DO need to remove the two brass roller pins, if you want to take out the nickel plated brass holder for that plastic bi-pin socket, as both the inner bore and outside surfaces will need to be cleaned to remove oxidation from contact surfaces.
But there are other contact surfaces you need to clean also. BTW, unless the older M*gChr switch assemblies are made differently, you do NOT need to use a 2mm allen head wrench to remove the 2 brass roller pins for the cammed operation, the plastic bi-pin plug/socket (Ginseng calls is a receptacle). Just push on top of the bi-pin socket, with soft tool like a wooden dowel or pencil, and it will pop right out the bottom. The front of this plastic bi-pin socket has a slight 45 degree tapered edge, which is all that holds it in place with spring pressure from below. I haven't yet taken the bi-pin socket apart to take pictures of, but this also has thin electrical contacts that must be cleaned if you ever want maximum lumens coming out of a high-wattage upgrade bulb.
Too bad Ginseng doesn't have any close-up pictures to accompany, showing you how to do, with all of the instructions he has listed above. Of course, if he has spare time on his hands; I'll gladly add his sharp close-up pictures and instructions for the basic disassembly of the whole light (while I work on getting sharp pictures of the insides of the actual switch assembly) to my thread I'm working on. That would certainly be 'useful' and helpful to me, if no one else.
Oh ya, the M*gChr switch assembly, along with all new M*g switch assemblies, ships with 'new style' M*g rubber switch cover, no special rubber ships with the M*gChr anymore /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/frown.gif
BTW ag4gt, you might want to edit your thread title to state "M*gChr" as opposed to M*glite switch removal, they are different animals.
Edit: Oops, my bag 'ol rubber switch covers in my last order, does in fact have a special M*gChr switch cover with thick firm inner round piece of rubber to contact the clickie portion of the switch...my bad. I'm just a bit textually changed and have trouble understanding some descriptions of other CPF members...picture worth a thousand words /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif.