These are nice, they have a soft liner for easy in and out, low wear on finish. Fits L1P and HDC EDC lights equally well (longer/skinnier vs shorter/fatter, it's a wash, you get full velcro overlap with either). I found the same pouch less the horizontal carry loops at my local army/navy surplus store as a Victorinox accessory for carrying a swiss army knife, with their usual cross logo emboidered on the flap, six bucks.