Swede74
Enlightened
- Joined
- Sep 30, 2011
- Messages
- 577
I think you meant inexpensive. :laughing:Definitely recommended for the DIY club ... it's an expensive way to add a lot more versatility to the lights.
I think you meant inexpensive. :laughing:Definitely recommended for the DIY club ... it's an expensive way to add a lot more versatility to the lights.
Sorry I did ... always embarrassing to drop the negative ...I think you meant inexpensive. :laughing:
Yes, a very apt analysis. Total ability to do work is about the same for these battery categories, but there is the slight added advantage of the higher nominal voltage for 4xAA cells in series. To extend the analogy, even the newer 2550mAh Eneloop Pros are only roughly equivalent to the newer protected 3400mAh 18650s.For some reason I was expecting better performance from the seemingly new-ish "fat" 4xAA seems form factor; they're offering capabilities similar to high-performance 1x 18650 lights. Then I ran some basic numbers and realize that the nominal watt-hours of each package is similar (18650 doing 3.7V * 2600mAH for 9.62 W-H; LSD NiMH doing 1.2V * 2000mAH * 4 for 9.6 W-H), with the only advantage of 4xAA being a higher nominal voltage.
Glad to hear it. I have a few updates coming over the next few days.I am looking for a 4xaa thrower, so this was a big help!
Thanks, and :welcome:Wow, what for a great comparsion! Very helpful! Thanks for that!
Yes, there is not a lot in the 2xAA form factor any more - most have moved to the 4xAA class (for the greater output and runtime, I suspect).A 2xAA roundup would be great to see. Though, perhaps there's too much choice in that area for it to not appear overwhelming.
Yes, I get that a lot. I agree those can be quite helpful when trying to narrow down choices - but there are many pitfalls, and lots of reasons why I don't do it. To put it simply, I prefer to keep qualitative assessments (which are subjective) as separate from quantitative scores (which I reserve for objective measures).BTW, I think it would be great to see Selfbuilt's ratings for each light (perhaps on a scale of 1 to 10). I know there's probably reasons why he's hesitant to give recommendations, but it would still be nice to see.
It's a nice light - hope you enjoy it.I my D40A today and can't wait until it gets dark!