looks like the people have spoken!
you've pretty much heard good opinions that support one way or the other.
for me, I too believe SF lights are well worth the $$.
as others have already repeated... you have to experience a SF to see what all the hooplah is about!
(i havent read all the previosu posts so forgive me if this analogy has already been used)
it's much like trying to justify buying a high-end vehicle like a sports car or sports-ute, eh? Some people would never pay any of the extravagant prices for a genuine high-end vehicle.
I mean, let's face it: all vehicles bring us from Point A to Point B, that's it!
But still, the prices for vehicles range considerably. And as far as I can see, it has a lot to do with getting what you pay for! Driving a lower-end economy car just doesnt give the driver the same "experience" as driving a high-end luxury vehicle or the like. You still get from Point A to Point B in the economy vehicle. But those who own/drive higher-end vehicles will attest that there IS a difference! A huge difference!! Everything from quality to fuel economy to warranty to performance, blah blah blah. And to get the best of these attributes just plain COSTS more!
Back to flashlights - for me, I use my lights chasing after bad people in the dark... and sometimes that's even while I am at work!
But seriously, high-end lights help keep me alive. Period. And IMHO there is no price too high to pay as my life is pretty much priceless in my point of view.
As others have already expressed accurately... SF lights are high-end "tools" that get the job done. There are ohter tools out there, other brands that cost much less than SF... but I would not trust most of these lesser-performing tools when it's crunch-time, eh? As one of the very first posters already said... what's having a reliable high-end flashlight tool worth to you when things are starting to get dangerous...?
If you want the best-of-the-best... you pay for it up front.
(... and to be honest, us flashaholics are also great "rationalists" too...!)