Olight S1A & S2A (TIR Optic, XM-L2, 1xAA / 2xAA) Review

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
The S1A, S2A from Olight have been released with all "TIR optic and side switch". These are to give you intended throw with minimal spill and not only control on-off but perform mode changes.
I will start out with S1A, then the S2A.
.
.
1. S1A

S-0.jpg


S-1.jpg


The S1A comes in clear plastic container. There is an overview of features on the front and back of the packaging.
The light comes with removable pocket clip (attached), spare o-ring, wrist lanyard, 1xOlight lithium AA battery, user manual.
.
.
Manufacturer Specifications from Olight's website and user manual :

• Cree XM-L2 LED
• Powered by one AA battery. Conventional output : 0.5 lumens, 5 lumens, 50 lumens, 220 lumens,
• Strobe mode at 10Hz. Special output: turbo mode at 600 lumens (only available when 14500 rechargeable lithium battery is used)
• High light transmission rate TIR lens resulting in a balanced and useful beam
• Eco-friendly AL6061-T6 aluminum alloy body with anti-scratch Milspec type-III hard anodized finish and a blue PVD stainless steel ring on the switch and bezel
• Controlled by a thermal protection program, the turbo mode is limited to 1 minute and then the brightness gradually steps down to 50% of the initial brightness (only available when 14500 rechargeable lithium battery is used)
• Built-in timer: Short timer (3 minutes) or Long timer (9 minutes)
• Dimension : 79.5mm (Length) x 21mm (Head)
• Weight : 37.5g (without battery)

S-2.jpg

.
.
S-3.jpg


S-4-1.jpg


S-4-2.jpg


S-4-3.jpg


S-4-4.jpg


The S1A is quite small for its class. Overall build is quite similar to the S1 Baton I reviewed.
The hard(type III) anodizing is a matte black and no flaws on my sample. All labels are sharp and clear in bright white against the black background. The raised checkered pattern is present over most of the body. The light has no tail switch. Fit and finish look very good.

You can use 1xAA (1.2V Ni-MH or 1.5v Alkarine or 1.5V Lithium or 3.7v Li-ion rechargeable battery) in the light.
.
.
S-5.jpg


The light has 2 parts. The body is one piece with the head (i.e., the body has a built-in head). The pocket clip and side switch work as a good anti-roll device.
.
.
S-6.jpg


The light has a blue flat stainless steel bezel ring. The head has a clean looking cylindrical design with a hex-shaped neck which provides grip. There's an electronic side switch just on the neck. The side switch is silicon, and it has a good feel to touch and has short travel, which produces the same clicking sound as the S1. Like the S1, the S1A switch protrudes slightly, so the risk of accidental activation is not high. There's no low-voltage warning indication on the side switch.

The light has a deep-set positive (+) battery contact in the head. There is also a black plastic disc surrounding it, which acts as physical reverse-polarity protection feature to protect from incorrect battery installation. So flat-top cells will not work in the light.
.
.
S-7.jpg


S-8.jpg


The light uses a PMMA (Poly Methyl MethAcrylate or Acrylic Glass ) TIR lens without a reflector. The fit and finish look good.
.
.
S-9.jpg


The pocket clip looks sturdy and hold onto the light very securely. It is reversible, allowing both bezel-up or bezel-down.
.
.
S-10.jpg


The battery tube (i.e., body) is mostly covered in raised checkered portions with three flat faces where manufacturer, model name are printed on, and one of the flat faces where the clip is touching. With the pocket clip attached and other shapes on the head, overall grip is good. The wall thickness of the body is 2.0mm. The light feels solid.
.
.
S-11.jpg


The screw threads are square-cut of good quality. Threads are well machined, and anodized which allows the light to be locked-out when the tailcap is slightly loosened. As supplied, threads are well lubricated. Screw threads action is smooth with no cross-threading or squeaking in my sample.
.
.
S-12.jpg


There is a removable negative (-) spring come with a removable strong magnet on the inside of the tailcap. There is tiny hole on the side of the tailcap for lanyard or split-ring attachment. The magnet pull is strong, so it does pick up the battery through the negative spring, because the spring and the magnet are actually in contact. The light sticks to all the metal objects made with steel. If you don't want the magnet, you can remove it (i.e., you can take out the magnet by releasing the spring holding the magnet in place by prising the three edges of the spring out from under the recess on the tailcap). There is a raised checkered portions band on the tailcap. The S1A can tailstand stably as expected.
.
.
User Interface

There are two modes (i.e., general mode & strobe mode).

1) General mode
On-Off and output switching is controlled by the electronic switch. A quick press and release turns the light on, and another quick press and release turns the light off.

When on, holding down the switch will proceed Low -> Med. -> High -> Turbo (only available on a rechargeable Li-ion cell), in repeating sequence. To select your desired mode or output level, just release the switch. The light has mode memory, and remembers the last output level used when you turn the light off and back on, even after a battery change.

You can access Moonlight directly from "Off" by a sustained press of the switch for about 1.5 second. This means Moonlight is a separate mode from the above Low, Med. High, and Turbo. You can always turn the light on in the lowest possible mode if you want (i.e., no matter where you memorized it before). Mode cycling and memory works as before, once on.

Double quick click from Off will activate High or Turbo (only with a rechargeable Li-ion cell) directly.

2) Strobe mode
The "hidden" Strobe is accessed by triple-clicking the switch whatever mode the light is on (even Off). A single sustained press of the switch will return to the previous output level in general mode. The strobe has no memory.

3) Timer setting
The distinctive aspect of the light is a timer setting function.
Double quick click from On will activate "3 mins timer" which is presented as single flash. Another double click from On will activate "9 mins timer" which is presented as two flashes. You can swap between 3 mins and 9 mins timer setting by a double quick click. The light will automatically shut off once the timer is over.
.
.
S-13.jpg


From left to right, Olight Lithium AA, Olight S1A (XM-L2), Olight S15 (XM-L2), Xeno ES1 V2 ( XP-G2 R5), Fenix LD11 (XP-G2 R5).
.
.
S-14.jpg


From left to right, Olight Lithium AA, Olight S1A (XM-L2), Olight S15 (XM-L2), Xeno ES1 V2 ( XP-G2 R5), Fenix LD11 (XP-G2 R5).
.
.
Standby Current Drain

Due to the electronic side switch interface, the S1A is drawing a small current when the light is fully connected. I measured this current as 1.7μA and 5.5μA on Eneloop AA (2000mAh) and Soshine 14500 (800mAh) respectively. That would translate into around 134 years (Eneloop AA 2000mAh) and 16 years (Soshine 14500 800mAh) before it would be fully drained. This is quite negligible, not a concern. But I would recommend you to store the light locked-out when not in use for a long time or to prevent accidential activation.
.
.
Measured Dimensions
S-15.jpg

.
.
S-16.jpg


The S1A is compact and small. It is really good size to hold and use. You can use it as an 1xAA EDC light. Overall build quality is excellent.
.
.
PWM
S-17.jpg


The light shows no sign of PWM at all output levels with 1xEneloop AA. I notice there is no buzzing sound at any levels.
.
.
S-17-1.jpg


The light shows no sign of PWM at all output levels with 1xSoshine 14500. I notice there is no buzzing sound at any levels.
.
.
Runtime

S-18.jpg


The runtime to fall to 10% of its initial output from 30 seconds after the point the light is first turned on (i.e., based on ANSI FL-1) for Turbo is as follows :

S1A starts to step down gradually after 1 min runtime, and level off to around 54% of the initial output after 2 mins on 1x14500. This seems to be a timed drop-down, not a thermal sensor feature. Note that you can turn the light off-on to restore initial Turbo output. There are additional automatic step-downs in output as battery power depletes.
.
.
S-19.jpg


On High with 1xEneloop AA and 1xOlight Lithium AA, the light maintains almost flat regulation for an extended period, before step-down in output as battery power depletes. There are abrupt shut-off on both Eneloop and Olight Lithium at the end of runtime. It seems the light has over-discharge protection function and it turns off automatically at voltage of around 0.8V. This menas the S1A has a built-in over-discharge protection function in the light.
.
.
S-20.jpg


As you can see the above, the light on rechargeable 14500 will give you more than double output than on other batteries at initial runtime.
.
.
S-20-1.jpg


Output-runtime efficiency seems excellent, as expect for a current-controlled light.
.
.
Beamshot

1. White door beamshot (about 50cm from the white door) on max. output on 1xPanasonic Eneloop AA
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/25sec, Auto white balance
S-21.jpg
S-22.jpg

S-23.jpg
S-24.jpg

.
.
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/100sec, Auto white balance
S-25.jpg
S-26.jpg

S-27.jpg
S-28.jpg

.
.
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/800sec, Auto white balance
S-29.jpg
S-30.jpg

S-31.jpg
S-32.jpg

.
.
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/2000sec, Auto white balance'
S-33.jpg
S-34.jpg

S-35.jpg
S-36.jpg


The TIR optic gives you a well focused bright hot spot with a quite less bright spill which isn't perfectly circular, due to TIR optic at a very close distance (i.e., around ~50cm). As with almost optics, there is little side spill. The overall beam profile is better than expected. The beam is close to neutral tint in my sample. Overall beam profile and tint are quite similar to the S1.
.
.
2. 3.5m Indoor Beamshot on max. output on 1xPanasonic Eneloop AA
- ISO125, F/2.8, 1/10sec, Auto white balance
S-37.jpg

.
.
S-38.gif

.
.
3. 7.0m Indoor Beamshot on max. output on 1xPanasonic Eneloop AA
- ISO125, F/2.8, 1/10sec, Auto white balance
S-39.jpg

.
.
S-40.gif


The hot spot is wide and well focused for throw. Instead the side spill is minimal.
.
.
S-40-1.jpg


Moonlight mode shows a very nice lower low output level.
.
.
Overall Impressions

• Excellent build quality
• Very small 1xAA light
• The light can stably tailstand
• Anti-roll indentations on the body
• There's a possibility of accidental activation from off, due to the slightly protruded switch
• Small standby current drain (1.7uA) is inevitable, but not a concern
• Physical lockout function at the taicap
• Physical reverse polarity protection function
• Over-discharge protection feature
• No low-voltage warning indication when on
• Timer setting function
• True flat-top will not work in the light
• Mode memory for all output levels except Strobe
• You can use 1xNi-MH or 1xAlkaline or 1xLithium or 1xRechargeable 14500
• Excellent output-runtime efficiency
• High max. output
• Good mode spacing
• True Moonlight mode is available
• No sign of PWM flickers at any output modes even with a rechargeable 14500
• Beam pattern is intended for throw with minimal spill
• Overall beam tint is close to neutral white
.
.
.
.
2. S2A

S-41.jpg


S-42.jpg


The S2A comes in clear plastic container. There is an overview of specifications and features on the front and back of the packaging.
The light comes with removable pocket clip (attached), spare o-ring, wrist lanyard, 2xOlight lithium AA batteries, user manual.
.
.
Manufacturer Specifications from Olight's website and user manual :

• Cree XM-L2 LED
• Powered by two AA batteries
• Flashlight body wrapped with skin-safe silicon material of various colors for better hand grip
• High light transmission rate TIR lens resulting in a balanced beam
• Eco-friendly AL6061-T6 aluminum alloy body with anti-scratch Milspec type-III hard anodized finish
• Controlled by a thermal protection program. Tthe turbo mode is limited to 3 minutes. The brightness will gradually step down to the next level. The flashlight will need to cool down to access the turbo mode again.
• Built-in timer : Short timer (3 minutes) or Long timer (9 minutes)
• Dimension : 132mm (Length) x 23mm (Head)
• Weight : 56g (without battery)

S-43.jpg

.
.
S-44.jpg


S-45-1.jpg


S-45-2.jpg


S-45-3.jpg


S-45-4.jpg


The S2A is compact for its class. Overall build is quite similar to the S1A.
The hard(type III) anodizing is a matte black and no flaws on my sample. All labels are sharp and clear in bright white against the black background. The whole battery tube is wrapped in a soft silicone for a good grip. This silicone comes in four colors (i.e., black, yellow, blue, gray). Note that yellow, blue, gray color are all florescent. The light has no tail switch. Fit and finish look very good.

You can use 2xAA (1.2V Ni-MH or 1.5v Alkarine or 1.5V Lithium in the light (i.e., not available with rechargeable 14500 cell in the light).
.
.
S-46.jpg


The light has 2 parts. The body is one piece with the head (i.e., the body has a built-in head). The pocket clip and side switch work as a good anti-roll device.
.
.
S-47.jpg


The light has a blue flat stainless steel bezel ring. The head has a clean looking cylindrical design with a hex-shaped neck which provides grip. There's an electronic side switch just on the neck. The side switch is silicon, and it has a good feel to touch and has short travel, which produces the same clicking sound as the S1A. Like the S1A, the S2A switch protrudes slightly, so the risk of accidental activation is not high. There's no low-voltage warning indication on the side switch.

The light has a positive (+) battery contact spring in the head. The light has an electrical reverse-polarity protection feature to protect from incorrect battery installation. So flat-top cells will work in the light.
.
.
S-48.jpg


S-49.jpg


The light uses a PMMA (Poly Methyl MethAcrylate or Acrylic Glass ) TIR lens without a reflector. The fit and finish look good.
.
.
S-50.jpg


The pocket clip looks sturdy and hold onto the light very securely. It is reversible, allowing both bezel-up or bezel-down.
.
.
S-51-1.jpg


S-51-2.jpg


The battery tube is wrapped in a soft silicone with narrow concentric ridges and a flat face. With the pocket clip attached and other shapes on the head, overall grip is excellent. The wall thickness of the body is 2.2mm including the silicone cover. The light feels solid.
.
.
S-52.jpg


The screw threads are square-cut of good quality. Threads are well machined, and anodized which allows the light to be locked-out when the tailcap is slightly loosened. As supplied, threads are well lubricated. Screw threads action is smooth with no cross-threading or squeaking in my sample.
.
.
S-53.jpg


There is a removable negative (-) spring in the tailcap. There is tiny hole on the side of the tailcap for lanyard or split-ring attachment. Unlike the S1A, the S2A doesn't have a magnet on the inside of the tailcap. There is a raised checkered portions band on the tailcap. The S2A can tailstand stably.
.
.
User Interface

The S1A and S2A have the same UI.
There are two modes (i.e., general mode & strobe mode).

1) General mode
On-Off and output switching is controlled by the electronic switch. A quick press and release turns the light on, and another quick press and release turns the light off.

When on, holding down the switch will proceed Low -> Med. -> High -> Turbo (only available on a rechargeable Li-ion cell), in repeating sequence. To select your desired mode or output level, just release the switch. The light has mode memory, and remembers the last output level used when you turn the light off and back on, even after a battery change.

You can access Moonlight directly from "Off" by a sustained press of the switch for about 1.5 second. This means Moonlight is a separate mode from the above Low, Med. High, and Turbo. You can always turn the light on in the lowest possible mode if you want (i.e., no matter where you memorized it before). Mode cycling and memory works as before, once on.

Double quick click from Off will activate High or Turbo (only with a rechargeable Li-ion cell) directly.

2) Strobe mode
The "hidden" Strobe is accessed by triple-clicking the switch whatever mode the light is on (even Off). A single sustained press of the switch will return to the previous output level in general mode. The strobe has no memory.

3) Timer setting
The distinctive aspect of the light is a timer setting function.
Double quick click from On will activate "3 mins timer" which is presented as single flash. Another double click from On will activate "9 mins timer" which is presented as two flashes. You can swap between 3 mins and 9 mins timer setting by a double quick click. The light will automatically shut off once the timer is over.
.
.
S-54.jpg


From left to right, Olight Lithium AA, Olight S2A (XM-L2), Olight S15 (XM-L2) with extender, Thrunite Neutron 2A ( XM-L), Niteye EYE12 (XM-L U2).
.
.
S-55.jpg


From left to right, Olight Lithium AA, Olight S2A (XM-L2), Olight S15 (XM-L2) with extender, Thrunite Neutron 2A ( XM-L), Niteye EYE12 (XM-L U2).
.
.
Standby Current Drain

Due to the electronic side switch interface, the S2A is drawing a small current when the light is fully connected. I measured this current as 1.2μA on 2xEneloop AA (2000mAh). That would translate into around 190 years before it would be fully drained. This is quite negligible, not a concern. But I would recommend you to store the light locked-out when not in use for a long time or to prevent accidential activation.
.
.
Measured Dimensions
S-56.jpg

.
.
S-57.jpg


The S2A is compact and lightweight. It is good size to hold and use. You can use it as an 2xAA EDC light. Overall build quality is excellent.
.
.
PWM
S-58.jpg


The light shows no sign of PWM at all output levels. I notice there is no buzzing sound at any levels.
.
.
Runtime

S-59.jpg


The runtime to fall to 10% of its initial output from 30 seconds after the point the light is first turned on (i.e., based on ANSI FL-1) for Turbo is as follows :

S2A starts to step down gradually after 3 min runtime, and level off to around 44% of the initial output after 1 mins on 2xEneloop AA and 2xSoshine 14500. This seems to be a timed drop-down, not a thermal sensor feature. You can turn the light off-on to restore initial Turbo output.

There are abrupt shut-off on Olight Lithium batteries at the end of runtime. I forcibly terminated runtime test on Eneloop to protect over-discharge of the cell earlier. Like the S1A, it seems the light has over-discharge protection function and it turns off automatically at voltage of around 0.8V. This menas the S2A has a built-in over-discharge protection function in the light.
.
.
S-60.jpg


Output-runtime efficiency seems good, as expect for a current-controlled light.
.
.
Beamshot

1. White door beamshot (about 50cm from the white door) on max. output on 2xPanasonic Eneloop AA
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/25sec, Auto white balance
S-61.jpg
S-62.jpg

S-63.jpg
S-64.jpg

.
.
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/100sec, Auto white balance
S-65.jpg
S-66.jpg

S-67.jpg
S-68.jpg

.
.
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/800sec, Auto white balance
S-69.jpg
S-70.jpg

S-71.jpg
S-72.jpg

.
.
- ISO125, F/8.0, 1/2000sec, Auto white balance'
S-73.jpg
S-74.jpg

S-75.jpg
S-76.jpg


The TIR optic gives you a well focused bright hot spot with a quite less bright spill which isn't perfectly circular, due to TIR optic at a very close distance (i.e., around ~50cm). As with almost optics, there is little side spill. The overall beam profile is better than expected. The beam is close to neutral tint in my sample. Overall beam profile and tint are quite the same as the S1A.
.
.
2. 3.5m Indoor Beamshot on max. output on 2xPanasonic Eneloop AA
- ISO125, F/2.8, 1/10sec, Auto white balance
S-77.jpg

.
.
S-78.gif

.
.
3. 7.0m Indoor Beamshot on max. output on 2xPanasonic Eneloop AA
- ISO125, F/2.8, 1/10sec, Auto white balance
S-79.jpg

.
.
S-80.gif


The hot spot is wide and well focused for throw. Instead the side spill is minimal.
.
.
S-80-1.jpg


Moonlight mode shows a very nice lower low output level, but brighter than the S1A.
.
.
Overall Impressions

• Excellent build quality
• Compact and lightweight 2xAA light
• The light can stably tailstand
• Anti-roll indentations on the body
• There's a possibility of accidental activation from off, due to the slightly protruded switch
• Small standby current drain (1.2uA) is inevitable, but not a concern
• Physical lockout function at the taicap
• Electrical reverse polarity protection function
• Over-discharge protection feature
• No low-voltage warning indication when on
• Timer setting function
• True flat-top will work in the light
• Mode memory for all output levels except Strobe
• You can use 2xNi-MH or 2xAlkaline or 2xLithium
• Good output-runtime efficiency
• High max. output
• Good mode spacing
• True Moonlight mode is available (but brighter than the S1A)
• No sign of PWM flickers at any output modes
• Beam pattern is intended for throw with minimal spill
• Overall beam tint is close to neutral white


The Olight S1A and S2A provided by Olight for review.
 
Last edited:

KeepingItLight

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
May 25, 2015
Messages
1,823
Location
California
Thanks for all your hard work! Your review is top-flight.

Maukka measured CCT and CRI (Ra) on his Olight S1 Copper Raw flashlight, yielding, respectively, 5410K and 68. Although a CRI of 68 is disappointing, a CCT of 5410K in a "cool-white" emitter is quite nice. Do you think it is possible that the cool-white Olight S1A and S2A have a similar CCT?
 

LeafSamurai

Enlightened
Joined
Oct 29, 2014
Messages
259
Location
Christchurch, NZ
Amazing review as always! I always end up buying the lights that you reviewed each time without fail. You are doing a great job convincing me to part with my hard earned cash lol.
 

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
Thanks for all your hard work! Your review is top-flight.

Maukka measured CCT and CRI (Ra) on his Olight S1 Copper Raw flashlight, yielding, respectively, 5410K and 68. Although a CRI of 68 is disappointing, a CCT of 5410K in a "cool-white" emitter is quite nice. Do you think it is possible that the cool-white Olight S1A and S2A have a similar CCT?

Thanks for your support. KeepingItLight!
According to Maukka's excellent measurements, the Copper raw material under the TIR lens tends to enhance the beam tint neutral, in my view. As a result, CCT seems to be somewhat dependant on the material of the light. I can hardly tell S1A and S2A have a similar CCT to S1 Copper Law.

I have compared to Olight i3E EOS, the hotspot of the S1A is similar to the i3E EOS in color temperature, but the side spill is cooler than the i3E EOS.

Amazing review as always! I always end up buying the lights that you reviewed each time without fail. You are doing a great job convincing me to part with my hard earned cash lol.

Thanks LeafSamurai! I'm relieved to hear it.
 

KeepingItLight

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
May 25, 2015
Messages
1,823
Location
California
So, maybe the Olight S1A and S2A are a bit cooler than the Olight S1 Copper Raw that maukka measured. If so, that's a small disappointment. I have the Copper Rose Gold S1, and it is every bit as neutral as the one maukka measured.
 

Lex Icon

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jan 25, 2015
Messages
109
So, maybe the Olight S1A and S2A are a bit cooler than the Olight S1 Copper Raw that maukka measured. If so, that's a small disappointment. I have the Copper Rose Gold S1, and it is every bit as neutral as the one maukka measured.

Whew...what a relief, I thought the new S1A was going to cost me money. Other manufacturers, flashlight modders, and LED makers must be grateful there are companies still looking backwards at previous 'Marketing flops' as a reason to limit tint and CRI options. Count me in as one of the lucky ones, untempted to spend money on a light useful to me. It answers the question of what happens to the less desirable or irregular LEDs failing standards and options demanded by more progressive light builders.
 

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
I just noticed that there are only a few threads on the tail-cap of the Olight S1A. From the pictures, there appear to be about two-and-a-half.

Like the Niteye EYE10, Sunwayman M11R, Olight S15, a few number of screw threads hold the head or tailcap (i.e., two full and a half turns), but I don't experience any issues.
 

adirondackdestroyer

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 31, 2005
Messages
2,018
I just received my 14500 Olight cells today and my god this thing is bright for being so small! I tested it in my old school lightbox (approximate lumens, but it should be pretty close) to be between 650-675 lumens on turbo with the 14500!
I LOVE the UI and honestly think the only way I could improve this light would be to add a way to lockout the switch so it can't accidently be turned on. Other than that it's damn near perfect, especially for the price I paid during the Olight 25% off sale!
 
Top