Rebel EOS/EOS II review.

Woods Walker

The Wood is cut, The Bacon is cooked, Now it’s tim
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
5,433
Location
New England woods.
I have tested both the updated EOS and EOS II headlamps. Years ago I tested out an EOS but despite liking the physical characteristics I found the light lacking the necessary flood output for my usage so it was rejected. However this update addresses the deficiencies of the old EOS and keeps everything I liked. Both headlamps have regulated output. This means that the initial brightness remains unchanged for a portion of the total runtime with reducing brightness after the headlamp falls out of regulation. This allows the user a fair warning to change the batteries. The updated EOS headlamps are now my favorite within the 3xAAA form factor.


4-Mode EOS Rebel:


http://www.princetontec.com/?q=node/65


The 4-mode EOS has a low, medium, high and a flashing mode. PT has the following ratings for each mode.


1. Low mode total burn time 121 hours with 50 hours regulated. 16m throw during regulation
2. Medium mode burn time 115 hours with 10 hours regulated. 32m throw during regulation.
3. High mode burn time 113 hours with 1 hour regulated. 54m throw during regulation.


The newer headlamp has the 50 lumen rating right on the package. Both the EOS and EOS II are physically similar. The PT marketing department has decided to finally give the type of LED in addition to "Maxbright". The Rebel 4-mode EOS is priced between 34-43 dollars

100_9958.jpg


Both updated headlamps have the same frosted optic. The older EOS has a clear optic. Here is a close up of the EOS frosted Optic.


100_9963.jpg


Both headlamps have the same battery installation. Just unscrew the nut on the back and 3xAAA batteries go into their clearly marked slots. I found battery installation on the EOS line to be far easier than my Tikka Plus or PT Aurora. Water resistance is achieved via O-ring. The headlamps are rated for Alkaline, Lithium and NIMH rechargeable. I run them both with 900 mAh Energizer NiMH and Duracell 800 mAh LSD NiMH batteries. Alkaline batteries are cheap and offer reasonable performance on the low modes but in my view suffer on high and sometimes leak. The NiMH batteries seem to offer better performance than Alkaline. Lithiums work great in the cold. I have not tested the EOS with Lithiums however if conventional wisdom holds I would expect longer regulated runtimes on Hi and standard performance on low. For longer term storage I use the LSD NiMH batteries as they will not self discharge over time and will not leak. My backup batteries are standard NiMH. These are topped off every month or so if not used. But they always seem to get used for weekend camping trips. Keep in mind that I am no expert on batteries and all of the above is based on field testing and educated guesses.


100_9960.jpg


Both headlamps are comfortable over extended usage. I found that the EOS was a bit bulkier than my other headlamps within this class. But not overly so. Here is a comparison photo for the EOS II, EOS, PT Aurora and Tikka Plus headlamps.

100_9995.jpg


The UI is fairly simple. The user can click though all modes. However if the user clicks though all four modes the headlamp will turn off. Also if the user waits for more than a few seconds to change the modes the headlamp will turn off. This is not that unusual. The headlamp starts off on high than moves to medium-low and ends with flashing mode.


Field testing:

For reasons that are unclear to me I found the 4-mode EOS to be brighter than the 2-mode industrial work light. The EOS II is a sold 50 lumens however I find it hard to believe that the 4-mode EOS isn't more than the listed 50 lumens. The optic was a bit more frosted. This could be intentional however don't know for certain. At first I felt the greater flood provided by the slightly more frosted optic would come at the expense of throw however both lights had equal throw (distance) but the 4-Mode EOS has greater flood. It really lights up the woods on high. I also found the 4-mode EOS has a warmer tint. I don't know if this greater output is because of the variations between LEDS or if they used a different Rebel. Being no expert on LEDs I can't say but this difference would only be noticed if some had both headlamps running at the same time like me during a test. Overall the 4-mode Rebel EOS has a very good balance between flood and throw. A near perfect beam for trail work.

I don't have any way to test the exact lumen rating so keep in mind that these ratings are based on comparisons with flashlights of known lumen ratings. On Hi the headlamp seemed like 50 plus lumens out front. It illuminated a good area and trail markers at some distance. It seemed to maintain the 50 plus lumen rating for longer than the listed 1 hour but it is hard to tell with the naked eye. On medium it seemed like about 25 lumens. I found the medium setting well within my comfort zone for both known trails and bushwhacking. I have not tested the full 10 hour regulated output at one time but feel I could hike all night on full regulation based on my overnight camping/hiking test. The low setting matched my E01 per my eye so guessing it is 6ish lumens. Great for camp work and a short walk to answer natures call however it was below my comfort level for night hikes. I didn't test the 50 hour low regulated output but see no reason not to trust PT on their ratings. The UL was easy to use but I didn't care for the flashing mode and wished the UI was more like the EOS II. After a few seconds the UI would reset to next click = off so I would have to restart the cycle to change modes. The EOS II could switch between modes without the light turning off after the mode is left on for an extended time. All that being said the UL of the 4-mode EOS is familiar to me. I just wish both headlamps would start on low rather than high.


The Rebel EOS II industrial work headlamp.


http://www.princetontec.com/?q=node/118


Both headlamps share many of the same characteristic so I will try and not repeat the same information for this review. The differences between the EOS/EOS II are within the UI. PT does mention something about chemical resistance plastic of the EOS II however I am betting that both headlamps are made out of the same stuff. The EOS II does come with a rubber strap in addition to the stretch cloth for attachment to a hard hat. The EOS II is a two mode light. Just high or low. The user can switch between modes by simply pressing the recessed button. The switch on both headlamps is a bit stiff but this is not a problem as it helps reduce accidental activation within someone's pack.


PT lists the ratings as the following:


1. High is 50 lumens with no throw rating.
2. Low is not listed.


The spotty listing is due to the packaging of the EOS II. Being an industrial work headlamp the packaging consists of a box with just the light and extra rubber strap in plastic wrap. No instructions are provided. But though testing I have found the high rating is a true solid 50 lumens with a longer than listed regulated runtime. Maybe two plus hours rather than the 1-1.5 of the 4-Mode EOS however this is just a guess based on my naked eye and maybe proven un true if anyone ever does a scientific test. I see no reason not to think the total runtime isn't near the 120ish hours of the 4-mode EOS. The low setting seemed like 10ish lumens. My test showed a regulated runtime of around 13-14 hours based on timed hikes/camping usage but again I could be wrong. I think maybe the total runtime would be between the medium and low modes on the 4-mode EOS. So guessing the runtime on low is 13 hours regulated with a total 114 hours.


Field testing:


The high worked great for bushwhacking and hard trail work. But it was a bit less in terms of flood than the 4-mode EOS with equal throw. I found the tint warmer than most of my headlamps but the 4-mode EOS has a better tint and overall nicer beam. However these differences can only be discerned if someone has both headlamps side by side and may be due to the variations within LEDS. They don't call it a lottery for no reason. In any case the EOS II for the most part like the 4-mode EOS has a good balance of flood and throw. The low setting is between the 4-mode EOS low and medium. It was just below my comfort level for night hikes. However it is very doable for familiar trails and workable for bushwhacking if looking to conserve on battery power. But during a test on an untraveled trail there were times I had to move up to high. The UI is my favorite of the two headlamps. Two modes and the light does not turn off between switching even if the mode is left on for a longer period. To turn the headlamp off I just hold the button down. Overall this was a joy but the lack of a medium mode was a real downer.


Beam shots:


Here is a beam shot of both headlamps on high including my Tikka plus for scale. The EOS II is on the far left, the 4-mode EOS in the middle and Tikka plus on the far right.


100_9987.jpg



It appears to me that the 4-mode EOS is both brighter and warmer than the 2-mode EOS work headlamp. The beam is near perfect. But despite the photos the EOS II is warmer than the Tikka plus and far less blue than my older PT Apex and Aurora 5mm LEDs. But the beam of the 4-Mode EOS is just darn right sweet however there is no guarantee that all EOS headlamps will reflect this.


A beam shot of the 2-mode EOS II high compared to the 4-mode EOS low.


100_9991.jpg



The 4-mode EOS low is nice and low just like it should be.


A beam shot of the 2-mode EOS II low compared to the 4-Mode EOS high.


100_9992.jpg


The EOS II low is between the 4-mode EOS low and medium.


Conclusion:

I think the newer updated EOS headlamps are very nice. They are my current favorite headlamps within this class. The light output is very good for my field use. Considering that most headlamps are used for extended periods of time PT showed a very good understanding of just what makes a great headlamp. The output, beam and tint all work together. Overall I prefer the 4-mode EOS as the one I own is brighter and has a better beam and tint. Also it is cheaper and more readily available. I hope this review was useful.

 
Last edited:

nzbazza

Enlightened
Joined
Apr 10, 2006
Messages
258
Location
New Zealand
Thanks for the review and the real world testing :twothumbs
I'm gonna have to get the new rebel EOS because the Zebralight H51 and H31 are taking a long time to come out.
 

Woods Walker

The Wood is cut, The Bacon is cooked, Now it’s tim
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
5,433
Location
New England woods.
Ok I have the numbers for Alkaline and Lithium batteries from the EOS instructions. All times are hours.

Alkaline.

Low. Regulated 50 overall burntime 121.
Med. Regulated 10 overall burntime 115.
High. Regulated (? typo) overall burntime 113.

Lithium

Low. Regulated 55 overall burntime 60.
Med. Regulated 17 overall buntime 20.
High. Regulated 6 overall burntime 8.

Clearly the lithium batteries run for longer regulated times but at the cost of the direct drive tail end. There was a typo with alkaline showing both regulated and overall burntimes on high being the same 113 hours. This can't be true. Thinking it maybe around 1-2 hours
 

Soleggen

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jan 5, 2007
Messages
7
Location
Oslo, Norway
Received my EOS with Rebel emitter today.

You're right about the burntime on high. It's 1 hour regulated.

Scanned the back of the package:

eosrebeloz1.jpg
 

kfallscody

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 18, 2007
Messages
36
Location
Klamath Falls, OR
I know this is not related to the review but... I am wanting to order one of these but want to make sure I get the newer 50 lumen model. It seems everywhere I look either the lumens are not listed or they are shown as 25(old model I believe?).

So I am asking where you all order yours from, to ensure you get the new model? Sadly there is no place in my pathetic town to purchase these units.. sigh.

Thanks in advance!
 

Woods Walker

The Wood is cut, The Bacon is cooked, Now it’s tim
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
5,433
Location
New England woods.
I got mine from Brightguy.com. They have all the new PT headlmaps. Just make certain you pick the right one with the Rebel LED.. I think the 4-mode EOS is about 33 bucks for that dealer.
 

whippoorwill

Enlightened
Joined
Oct 7, 2006
Messages
296
Location
Heart Of Dixie
I just got one off Ebay and it is impressive. One question though, is there any way to 'frost' the lens of the first gen EOS? I have thought about roughing it up with steel wool. Any ideas?
 

adirondackdestroyer

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 31, 2005
Messages
2,018
I picked one of the 4 mode Rebel versions yesterday at ****s Sporting Goods. They had it on sale for $40.
I'm pretty impressed with the perfect smooth beam it puts out. I tested the output in my homemade lightbox and here are the results:

high = 50.1 lumens
medium = 18.3 lumens
low = 5 lumens

I wasn't sure what Princeton Tec claimed for the output of the medium and low settings, but my readings were spot on for the high setting.
 

Woods Walker

The Wood is cut, The Bacon is cooked, Now it’s tim
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
5,433
Location
New England woods.
I picked one of the 4 mode Rebel versions yesterday at ****s Sporting Goods. They had it on sale for $40.
I'm pretty impressed with the perfect smooth beam it puts out. I tested the output in my homemade lightbox and here are the results:

high = 50.1 lumens
medium = 18.3 lumens
low = 5 lumens

I wasn't sure what Princeton Tec claimed for the output of the medium and low settings, but my readings were spot on for the high setting.


Thanks I was thinking more like 25 for the med but heck if my eye could tell 18 for lower 20's. The low seems spot on. It is a nice low low. Something that is in short supply these days.
 

adirondackdestroyer

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 31, 2005
Messages
2,018
Thanks I was thinking more like 25 for the med but heck if my eye could tell 18 for lower 20's. The low seems spot on. It is a nice low low. Something that is in short supply these days.

The more I use this light the more I like it! I love how smooth the beam is and it's perfect for up close use. This would be the ultimate headlamp if it went Low-Medium-High-Flash.
Does anyone know if you can buy just the bike attachment for this light?

I forgot to mention that the lux on high was 510.
 

Woods Walker

The Wood is cut, The Bacon is cooked, Now it’s tim
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
5,433
Location
New England woods.
I know that PT makes a bike EOS. Yea it has one of the best beams I ever seen for a 3xAAA headlamp or most any other for that matter. The tint of the Rebel LED is nice too as there is much less blue etc. More warmer than most Cree or 5mm LEDs.
 

Mundele

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 30, 2003
Messages
196
Location
Knoxville, TN
I know that PT makes a bike EOS. Yea it has one of the best beams I ever seen for a 3xAAA headlamp or most any other for that matter. The tint of the Rebel LED is nice too as there is much less blue etc. More warmer than most Cree or 5m LEDs.

Ive got both. Got the "EOS Bike" One is warmer than the other. The big difference is that the bike version has a clip on the back that snaps onto either a headband or a bike attachment. It works great but the added width (1/4" or so) puts the light a bit more forward on your head and for me is a noticeable difference. It also has a velcro type strap that you can use to attach the light to your helmet.

Did some night riding a few weeks back and I had one EOS on my helmet and one mounted on the bike. I much preferred the helmet mounted one and just turned the other off.

--Matt
 
Top