SaturnNyne
Enlightened
Yes, a few, in the official thread.
Novatac OR RA Clicky..What would you have?
- Thread starter Kamakazikev24
- Start date
Help Support Candle Power Flashlight Forum
Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
I'm just wondering which one is better. They seem pretty similar to me. Is it the durability, output (I believe the Clicky is 140 while Novatac is 120), or UI? Please give an explanation of which one you like more and why. :twothumbs
I'm just wondering which one is better. They seem pretty similar to me. Is it the durability, output (I believe the Clicky is 140 while Novatac is 120), or UI? Please give an explanation of which one you like more and why. :twothumbs
Moka
Enlightened
Re: Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
I personally choose the Ra Clicky,
140 is a burst mode, last for 10seconds then reverts to 100Lm, you get an awesome Runtime with the clicky and the think that drew me personally to it the most is the durability of the Clicky... 2.8mm thick glass lens vs 1.8mm poly-carb IIRC, and fully potted electronics, I'm loving mine, a great torch!
Just my .02 FWIW
I personally choose the Ra Clicky,
140 is a burst mode, last for 10seconds then reverts to 100Lm, you get an awesome Runtime with the clicky and the think that drew me personally to it the most is the durability of the Clicky... 2.8mm thick glass lens vs 1.8mm poly-carb IIRC, and fully potted electronics, I'm loving mine, a great torch!
Just my .02 FWIW
Kamakazikev24
Enlightened
Re: Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
Clicky is a great size and great runtime.
Read the thread on it though and you will see various problems which are in the process of getting sorted, bad ano, flashing, flickering, bezel not lining up, tailcap not fitted properly, low level flickering, coating on the lens rubs off easily, ect ect.
I ended up returning mine and got a cheaper Novatac 120P. It's perfect in every way.
Clicky is a great size and great runtime.
Read the thread on it though and you will see various problems which are in the process of getting sorted, bad ano, flashing, flickering, bezel not lining up, tailcap not fitted properly, low level flickering, coating on the lens rubs off easily, ect ect.
I ended up returning mine and got a cheaper Novatac 120P. It's perfect in every way.
Last edited:
sappyg
Enlightened
Re: Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
this question is like asking someone what their favorite color is.
1. it really does'nt matter what their favorite color is.
2. both lights are different enough that they may suite others better depending on budget, requirements, and taste.
both novatacs and RA clicky's have had issues is the past. both companies appear to work to satisfy their customers.
the OP's use of the word "better" is too open ended without establishing exactly how the term "better" is to be used.....
to me i would think there are several ways to interpret "better":
cost= novatac
technology= clicky
innovation= clicky
run time= clicky
UI= toss up
customer service= toss up
clip design= novatac
personal preference= novatac
out put= toss up
durability= toss up
based on my interpretation above they look like they are about equal. one will be better suited for others depending one their needs.
this question is like asking someone what their favorite color is.
1. it really does'nt matter what their favorite color is.
2. both lights are different enough that they may suite others better depending on budget, requirements, and taste.
both novatacs and RA clicky's have had issues is the past. both companies appear to work to satisfy their customers.
the OP's use of the word "better" is too open ended without establishing exactly how the term "better" is to be used.....
to me i would think there are several ways to interpret "better":
cost= novatac
technology= clicky
innovation= clicky
run time= clicky
UI= toss up
customer service= toss up
clip design= novatac
personal preference= novatac
out put= toss up
durability= toss up
based on my interpretation above they look like they are about equal. one will be better suited for others depending one their needs.
SnWnMe
Enlightened
Re: Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
The Clicky is a bigger Novatac 120P with longer runtime.
Or
The Novatac 120P is a smaller Clicky that costs less.
Burst is a feature that IMO, is necessary to show that the Clicky is much more than a longer running but more expensive and less pocketable Novatac.
The Clicky is a bigger Novatac 120P with longer runtime.
Or
The Novatac 120P is a smaller Clicky that costs less.
Burst is a feature that IMO, is necessary to show that the Clicky is much more than a longer running but more expensive and less pocketable Novatac.
HoopleHead
Flashlight Enthusiast
sappyg
Enlightened
Re: Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
now this is interesting.... SnWnMe suggests that the burst feature is the devinative matter between the 2 lights. that could be. i don't know. i don't think that 10 seconds at 140 lumin is a big need for me and my uses but it could be for others.
unfortunately cost is an issue in most decissions we make. is 10 seconds of 140 lumin burst worth having a "less pocketable" and "more expensive" light with longer run times? only the end user can answer that.
i think it's time the OP was more specific about what is "better" or what he use is for the 2 lights. which is better chevy or ford? infiniti or lexus? the answer probably something in between.
now this is interesting.... SnWnMe suggests that the burst feature is the devinative matter between the 2 lights. that could be. i don't know. i don't think that 10 seconds at 140 lumin is a big need for me and my uses but it could be for others.
unfortunately cost is an issue in most decissions we make. is 10 seconds of 140 lumin burst worth having a "less pocketable" and "more expensive" light with longer run times? only the end user can answer that.
i think it's time the OP was more specific about what is "better" or what he use is for the 2 lights. which is better chevy or ford? infiniti or lexus? the answer probably something in between.
Last edited:
Re: Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
I have, well had, both of them. Two 120P's and one Clicky. The Clicky is actually easier to carry then the Novatac it seems smaller and it is definitely thinner. The Novatac is a great light, if its money, then get the Novatac. I decided to sell my Novatac and keep the Clicky because I personally like it better and I have not had any of the listed problems. Just lucky I guess.
I have, well had, both of them. Two 120P's and one Clicky. The Clicky is actually easier to carry then the Novatac it seems smaller and it is definitely thinner. The Novatac is a great light, if its money, then get the Novatac. I decided to sell my Novatac and keep the Clicky because I personally like it better and I have not had any of the listed problems. Just lucky I guess.
Moka
Enlightened
Re: Ra Clicky vs. Novatac 120P
I have to say though it is unfortunate there are some inherent problems with the Clicky, perhaps check out the clicky thread and weigh up whether you wish to take the plunge... To let you know though if you order from Henry directly they're coming out with the newer firmware in which the flickering and other firmware issues are being fixed...
Some food for thought for ya =D :thumbsup:
I have to say though it is unfortunate there are some inherent problems with the Clicky, perhaps check out the clicky thread and weigh up whether you wish to take the plunge... To let you know though if you order from Henry directly they're coming out with the newer firmware in which the flickering and other firmware issues are being fixed...
Some food for thought for ya =D :thumbsup:
benchmade_boy
Flashlight Enthusiast
I am trying to decide this myself. The price seems to be very comparable to the novatacs. Are these out yet? what else can you get for the Ra's, can you get parts for the bezels? can you get any clips for them? Whats the best place to buy them?
Thanks
Thanks
LLCoolBeans
Flashlight Enthusiast
Yes, they are "out".
Manufacturer's website:
http://www.ralights.com/?id=Home
Dealers:
http://www.ralights.com/?id=Dealers
There are 4 factory bezels at this time, all the same style/shape. One Titanium the rest are SS. One is bare SS and two are black. There are two black coatings one less expensive and less durable and one more expensive and more durable.
There is a factory clip it comes in black or chrome. The old ARC4 clip also fits with minor modification.
The light is newly released, so there are no aftermarket parts yet availible. However, you can bet the modders are already on that.
Sgt. LED
Flashaholic
Yep.
benchmade_boy
Flashlight Enthusiast
So is there anyway to program the Ra tactical clicky, or any of them for that fact to go to the lowest setting when you turn it on? Or does it only go to the hightest?
I hope someone will make an after market bezel with trits in it. Somthing like Peu made for the HDS.
Dang now O just need to decide if I want the Ra or Novatac.
Thanks for the help beans
I hope someone will make an after market bezel with trits in it. Somthing like Peu made for the HDS.
Dang now O just need to decide if I want the Ra or Novatac.
Thanks for the help beans
LLCoolBeans
Flashlight Enthusiast
You can program it however you like it. All the Clicky models share the same electronics and software. The Executive and Tactical models have different default settings, but you can set ether up however you like.
There are five options and over twenty brightness settings to choose from.
Have a look at the users manuals on the Ra website.
You can set it to turn on to the lowest or the highest or whatever you want. You can also turn that off entirely and Clicky will turn on to the setting you were last using. NovaTac has these same features.
Last edited:
benchmade_boy
Flashlight Enthusiast
One last question for you, Are Novatacs made overseas now? Or are they still made here in the states?
LLCoolBeans
Flashlight Enthusiast
I don't care to speculate, as far as I know, they claim that they are.
Certain parts must be made overseas, like emitters, for example.
balou
Enlightened
what was that talking about the HDS being more expensive...
Novatac EDC-P MSRP is $189
HDS EDC Executive is $99
Am I missing something? Did the prices go down?
Oh and why the hell did I buy a D10 when in reality I wanted a HDS? :mecry:
(oh yeah, $50 price limit...)
Novatac EDC-P MSRP is $189
HDS EDC Executive is $99
Am I missing something? Did the prices go down?
Oh and why the hell did I buy a D10 when in reality I wanted a HDS? :mecry:
(oh yeah, $50 price limit...)
LLCoolBeans
Flashlight Enthusiast
Yes, the prices have come down some. Also, two economy models (EDC Executive and EDC Tactical) were added to the line-up.
balou
Enlightened
...well, as far as you can call a 120 lumen light an 'economy' model
(same as the novatac, vs 140 lumens for the other hds). There doesn't seem to be any other difference, or is there?
(same as the novatac, vs 140 lumens for the other hds). There doesn't seem to be any other difference, or is there?
