Re: 24W HID flashlight? - BrightStar + Photos
Hi - Just got my BrightStar P101-HID. Got it direct from China/Taiwan as living in England this seems sensible compared to going via USA. This is what you get in the box
I have been looking at the photos posted of this and the AELight-HID with great interest while waiting for mine to arrive. Now I have compared the photos and rubric with mine and it seems that there is some similarity between the two products - both having components from China/Taiwan ! and some differences.
Externally the head assembly is quite different in shape and to some extent form - The BS has a filter ring threaded onto the front (std 62mm camera) that holds the supplied plastic film filters- Maybe the AE has the thread to add camera lens type filters? I haven't seen any photos of the AE head taken apart yet so I can't tell.
This shows the major parts in a state of some disassembly. The BS has a plastic spacer ring that locates the lamp/mirror assembly to the back of the glass lens ( Is this the same in the AE ?) You can also see that the Ballast (Plugged to the back of the lamp assembly) has the same code number as the AE model - PL024A******* /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/thinking.gif
The case of the battery pack appears to be identical but I haven't seen any pictures of the internals of the AE to compare to those of the BS internals posted by
AW Re: AE Powerlight 24W HID
The tail switch also seems to be very similar but I haven't broken mine to find out if it is the same as the unmodified AE early model, which some members have broken, ( is there a new version for AE yet ?) or different ?
The next photo shows the tail switch assembly which has 3 rubber O rings and an aluminium threaded mount - but I don't know how far this aluminium goes into the plastic tail cap - This seems to be the area of the weakpoint found in the early AE versions - The AE model does come with extra head and tail rubber protectors and that seems like a good idea.
These are really substantial products with the BS weighing in at 1.168 kilo (2.57 lbs.) which is a good hefting weight that is almost exactly the same as the published weight of the AE ( anybody care to weigh an AE model ?)
Here is a visual comparison with :-
6C-Mag : 2D-Mag : Walther Tac 2xCR123A
Both models come with subtly different rubber rings and shoulder straps ! and the AE has a supplied bag. The BS body has two knurled areas that are quite usefully placed but are not as deep as one finds on a MagLite (Thick aircraft aluminium !)
The BS charger system seems fine and as it charges the LED gradually goes from RED to ORANGE to GREEN. The supplied charging system is not as shown on the websites as the mains adapter plugs directly into a wall socket, not via a cable as shown - this, or the 12/24volt car/truck lead, plugs into the charger that then connects to the base of the HID via a rubber plug protected socket.
I don't have any way to objectively test the brightness but it does seem very bright.
(f4.0 - 1/60sec - Iso200)
This is on my ceiling and you can just see that there is a certain area of colour fringing (Pinkish) at this close range. The bulb strikes purple and then quickly brightens and settles to a very nice white shade. Bright hot spot and a fairly even area of useful sidespill.
Trees, a moth and a plane
( 5sec. f4.2 iso200 50mm equiv )(Hand held - poor focus - sorry)
Lombardy Poplars, more trees and some apples !
All in all - /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif
Pretty good so far - any questions ?
Petrev