NO two lights of the same type have exactly the same performance characteristics. Variations in the components of the circuits, LEDs, etc. will cause them all to be a little different.
Plus, the lumen readings I get are ESTIMATES, not difinitive scientific mesasurements, and therefore are open to error. If anyone wants to send the $20,000 for the Integrating Sphere and associated calibration equipment, I'll be happy to get accurate measurements... No takers? Rats.
The difference in lumen output between Chevrofreak's and my measurements is less than 7%, and almost anything could account for that little of a difference, including mistakes in taking the readings... :shrug: Considering the level of sophistication we have access to, I would say that we did a surprisingly good job by getting readings that close!