I'm scratching my head over the release of the H31r and the H51r. ... So...who do these appeal to? And for what purpose?
I use mine on low-medium for hiking in woods (high-medium if it's a brighter night). Great for walking down a dark trail without breaking my leg, and impact on night vision is a lot less than a white light. Also I can fire it up to high to see something a little farther away, again without nearly the penalty a white light would have on my dark vision--I generally walk at night without a light on and just turn it on briefly for especially dark stretches under tree cover or if there's no moon at all, so maintaining my dark adaptation is important to me. 675 nm is better for night vision--but it's so close to the limit of human visibility that it'd have to be incredibly bright to be of any use for walking on uneven terrain. My H51r is a great compromise between having enough light and maintaining my night vision. I also use it on the low modes for night photograpy and astrophotography--the lowest for basic dial and knob settings if it's really dark, the "high" low for reading LCD screens when I have to. "Low" low has no noticeable affect on my dark vision (it's VERY low); "high" low only a slight affect that my dark-adapted vision recovers from pretty quickly.
So scratch no longer--maybe it doesn't work for you, but it does for me and for at least enough other people to make it worthwhile for Zebralight to keep making these things.
And if you can't find an H50r-style light that's wide and diffuse enough for you, sticking something over the lens of an H51r or H31r takes only a few seconds (hint: saran wrap is a cheap and easy way to keep anything in place; just keep as much of the head uncovered as possible for cooling if you plan to use high modes).