10 LED flashlight in Maplin - Worth buying?

Candle Power Forums

Help Support Candle Power:

Zelandeth

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 28, 2002
Messages
1,194
City & State/Province
Northeast Scotland (Aberdeenshire)
10 LED Flashlight at Maplin - £17.99

maplin01.jpg


Will be going in on Thursday, spotted this last week, just wondering whether anyone's going to tell me to avoid it, or whether it's a good choice for my first "real" LED flashlight. Looked pretty well put together anyway.

Thanks,
Zel.
 
Looks nice in that photo. Mind doing a little review after you've finished playing with it? Might get one myself if it's any good. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif
 
I bought one a couple of weeks ago. It's reasonably made although the lens is made from very cheap plastic. It has two settings - the first click puts on 3 leds, the second lights up all ten, and the third click turns it off. This isn't mentioned on the web site (at least it wasn't when I bought it) and is a very pleasant surprise. The 3 leds is easily bright enough to see around the house and with all 10 it's brighter than my lucido C10 (lightwave 4000). It runs on 4 AA batteries that fit into a sleeve that can only be inserted the correct way into the body and it has a good ribbed rubber grip. Incase you haven't guessed by now, I can definitely recommend it !
 
Hmm, can't tell from the pic. Anyone know if it'd be possible to replace the lens?

That point aside, I'm certainly going to get one now.

OK. Now I'm wishing Thursday would hurry up and get here...if they've run out by the time I get there - I'm probably going to be "irriaited"
 
You can always purchase one from the maplin website like I did - the delivery was very quick. The lens isn't THAT bad - just not up to the standards of surefire, streamlight etc.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Nah, think I'll just go in on Thursday, if they're out of stock, then I'll resort to the site.

Don't know if it's just me, but there's something I like about actually going and physically picking it from the shelf and going to pay for it and such like.

Also, I ain't 18 until April 2nd...which means no credit card yet. And my mother is going to have a fit when she finds I've bought another flashlight as it is, never mind if I ask to borrow her credit card to do so /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/tongue.gif Last time was quite interesting enough...
 
I agree about going and buying from the shop. If I didn't live in the middle of nowhere I'd do the same.

I've learned to be quite creative about hiding my flashlight purchases from my girlfriend. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif
 
looks very interesting i was just about to buy a SL 4AA LED, but wondering whether this would be better/cheaper?
 
Got one for my mom who live in Tusin, California, where I expect to have brownouts and blackouts like last year. It's a good flashlight with sufficient light for indoor use, i.e. not much throw to speak of. However, I think the rubber sleeve is too thin to be durable.
 
I haven't held one in my hands, it's true, butI have to say I'm not keen on this light, by the look of it. Here's why...

LEDs guarenteed (sic) to last a lifetime
"A lifetime" is a very ambiguous term, used by many advertisers over the years to hype second rate products. How long is "a lifetime" ? The lifetime of a moth can be measured in weeks. Also what is the point of having such a long-lasting lightsource if, say, the switch is bad ?

Water resistant
How water resistant, exactly ? Splash ? Weather ? Dunk ? Submersible ? It doesn't say, which makes me suspicious. Another ambiguous description.

Stylish, rugged design
Well, thats a matter of taste. The appearance of this unit certainly doesn't light my blue touchpaper, but maybe that's just me being Mr. Picky.

Up to 80 hours battery life
Is that all ? Maybe this is why the dual power setting isn't mentioned, maybe they are referring to the battery life for the 3 LED setting. The Princeton Tec Attitude (for example) will last "up to" 150 hours on 4x AAA batteries - almost twice as long. The Lightwave 4000 (or Lucido C10, as it is known in Europe) lasts "up to" 350 hours on 3x D cells. Surely this alone makes this light a false economy, the cost of the extra batteries you will have to buy in the long term will surely eat into the money you have "saved".

Aluminium and rubber body
There's aluminium and there's aluminium. What sort of aluminium ? Aircraft grade ? I doubt it. According to Alans post above, the rubber grip doesn't sound like it will last. What then ? Slippery bare metal. This sounds like a cheap alternative to machining a proper grip into the metalwork.

Includes carry strap and 4 x AA batteries
Well whoopee-doo. Not exactly a unique feature, is it ?

I'd do yourself a favour, Zelandeth and spend your hard-earned on something made by a well-known manufacturer with a proven track record. It may cost you more in the short term, but will pay you back in buckets over the years to come. What I've seen here certainly hasn't sent me scouring the web for the manufacturer and I don't think I want to stock it myself. It strikes me as a "bandwagon" product, made to cash in rather than to genuinely serve the user long term.

The father of a friend recently expressed interest in what I had to offer, but decided to opt for a 4 LED torch on offer for £12.99 in a national newspaper, on the grounds that it was half the price of anything I had to offer. He ordered it, it arrived. Two LEDs worked OK, one was dim and the other was dead. The black finish on the torch was uneven and there was no grip at all. Back it went and he's asked me to drop around with the toy box sometime so he can pick "something decent".

As a general point: it is often better to spend "too much" money on something than too little. That way all you lose is a little money, of which there will be more one day. If you go for the cheap option you risk losing everything, because what you are buying may not be up to the job and could leave you high and dry. So when you are considering the cheapest option, don't forget to add something extra to the price to cover you in emergencies. When you do that you will find that you have the money for something better.
 
For the price, it is much better value than the Lucido C10. I have both, and if I could only keep one it would definitely be the one from maplin.
 
The C10 is just too big and heavy for the output, in my opinion. Ok, the batteries will last for days, but it's SO much dimmer than the maplin flashlight. The maplin one is bright enough to walk my dog with whilst the C10 is probably best suited to clubbing seals with.
 
I just got one in from the fellow on ebay. I'm really new on this stuff, a few homemade units, a Lightwave 2000, Reactor2. (I'm still waiting for an Arc AAA and a BB400 for a mini-mag), ordered and waiting. Regarding the AT-100 10 led flashlight, I like it! It's well machined from aluminum, the rubber part is crummy (not really that important)but the beam is very white and clean. Whiter than my Reactor, but not as focused. It's a bit diffuse, doesn't throw a tight beam, but great for looking around the garage or walking down the driveway. Seems to be fairly well made, feels solid in the hand. I'm using it with 4 NiMH 1.2V cells and find it to be adequately bright - beats the Lightwave 2000 which is my favorite "smooth flood light". It's quite a bit brighter with Alkaline AAs, but I prefer NiMH. I tried to take it apart to possibly optimize it for NiMH, but I couldn't find a current limiting resistor - just a 1N400x diode that somehow switches from 3 to 10 leds. All in all, it's a nice light for a reasonable price. I just wonder if the switch will last for a while? My feeling: it's cheap and it works good, the leds are bright and very white. Well worth the money if you like flashlights!
Rob
 
[ QUOTE ]
dirobesh said:
The C10 is just too big and heavy for the output, in my opinion...

[/ QUOTE ]
Fair enough. The light that's right for you is the one that does what you want/need - something which is different for everyone. Apart from that, you actually own one and I don't.

I was just a tad suspicious as it seemed to be advertised in somewhat vague terms and I still have a couple of reservations about the finish in terms of the lens and grip.

Now then... where's that seal /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif
 
Drat Drat Drat Drat....sold out darnit!

Guess I'll just have to wait then. None left in the store, and I can't afford the normal £24.99 price.

No amount of nagging, pleading or anything else that I could think of would convince my mother to let me use her credit card to get it from the site. OK, I have the number anyway, but know better than to use it. I do have *some* self-preservation instincts!

Wish April 2nd would hurry up and get here so that I can actually get one of my own, then every time I want to order anything I don't have to try and think of a good excuse...

There'll be other chances I'm sure. Not this month though...car tax is up at the end...that's another £58 I could do without spending...

Zel.
 
Sounds interesting, maybe a decent glove box light if loaded with lithium AA's...

Jon
 
The Streamlight 3C and the InReTECH 20 LED Mag replacement module are two good alternatives to this.
 
Back
Top