2xAA, Strike Bezel, highest lux (throw)

Candle Power Forums

Help Support Candle Power:

Status
Not open for further replies.

AusKipper

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
723
Are there any flashlights out there that are 2xAA batteries, with a strike bezel, and if theres more than 1 (i cant find one) which one throws farthest?

BTW im really after a propper strike bezel, not just the milder crenelations (its for a younger female traveling to multiple countries overseas)

USB charging is a bonus.

The Klarus RS1A seems to be the best option I can find so far but its only 1xAA im really after a little more grunt.
 
2xAA, Strike Bezel, highest lux (throw)

Are there any flashlights out there that are 2xAA batteries, with a strike bezel, and if theres more than 1 (i cant find one) which one throws farthest?

BTW im really after a propper strike bezel, not just the milder crenelations (its for a younger female traveling to multiple countries overseas)

USB charging is a bonus.

The Klarus RS1A seems to be the best option I can find so far but its only 1xAA im really after a little more grunt.


so among the 1 & 2 AA's you've looked at so far, the max throw was from a single cell?! Must be pretty good performer, what was its lux rating btw?
 
I believe the Quark Turbo AA2 still holds the highest throw numbers in Selfbuilt's 2xAA reviews. This light is also a Lego favorite pocket thrower for some of us, using 1xAA tubes and running 14500s (I also like 3V CRAAs, but they are often sold out). Your a strike bezel requirement really limits your options, and IMHO, the one on that RS1A doesn't look much more effective than no strike bezel. Finally, if you see spec quotes that exceed 200 lumen-hrs (lumens x hrs) per 2000 mah Eneloop on any mode, it's exaggeration. I have a good collection of the best 1xAAs and test with both a light meter and stopwatch and find the best lights to be far more on level playing field than a comparison of their spec sheets might otherwise suggest.
 
so among the 1 & 2 AA's you've looked at so far, the max throw was from a single cell?! Must be pretty good performer, what was its lux rating btw?

Nope, its the only AA light from a reputable manufacturer I have found with a strike bezel.

It was rated by the FL1 standard to 100m of throw, not sure what that translates into for lux at 1 meter.
 
I believe the Quark Turbo AA2 still holds the highest throw numbers in Selfbuilt's 2xAA reviews. This light is also a Lego favorite pocket thrower for some of us, using 1xAA tubes and running 14500s (I also like 3V CRAAs, but they are often sold out). Your a strike bezel requirement really limits your options, and IMHO, the one on that RS1A doesn't look much more effective than no strike bezel. Finally, if you see spec quotes that exceed 200 lumen-hrs (lumens x hrs) per 2000 mah Eneloop on any mode, it's exaggeration. I have a good collection of the best 1xAAs and test with both a light meter and stopwatch and find the best lights to be far more on level playing field than a comparison of their spec sheets might otherwise suggest.

I actually have the Quark Turbo AA for myself (my flashlights list in my sig is badly outdated) and though I like the light the strike bezel really is a mandatory requirement for this light. The one on the RS1A looks reasonably decent to me, not as good as the one on my surefire defender but still decent.

There are a number of options on dealextreme but I really didnt want to go down the "chinese-fire" rout...
 
I just don't understand the fascination with strike bezels, but to each their own. It's more likely to just tear up her bag or pocket, or wherever she carries it than aid her in an iffy situation.

If her travel will be into/out of the US, a lgiht with an aggressive bezel is likely to attract unwanted attention from the TSA if carried in the cabin. It may be seen as a "sharp" or dangererous object, and confiscated. Tools are allowed, but if it's longer than 7", it can't be carried in the cabin.

I'd suggest something simple that's easy to keep in pocket or bag, like your Quark or a Preon variant. Solid build, easy to find batteries for, good output, and still able to effectively poke things with if needed.
 
I just don't understand the fascination with strike bezels, but to each their own. It's more likely to just tear up her bag or pocket, or wherever she carries it than aid her in an iffy situation.

If her travel will be into/out of the US, a lgiht with an aggressive bezel is likely to attract unwanted attention from the TSA if carried in the cabin. It may be seen as a "sharp" or dangererous object, and confiscated. Tools are allowed, but if it's longer than 7", it can't be carried in the cabin.

I'd suggest something simple that's easy to keep in pocket or bag, like your Quark or a Preon variant. Solid build, easy to find batteries for, good output, and still able to effectively poke things with if needed.

+1, but if you're still intent on your original search, Have a look at the Xeno E06, compatible with the Xeno ST03 strike bezel (which I think is compatible with Surefire Z44 bezels... so by that logic, all of the spikey bezels for the Z44 bezel should be Xeno E06 compatible).

The XP-G version was measured at 3580lux @1m byernsanada in this review. There is a newer XM-L version, also driven at 600ma, you could mod it to a XP-G2 for more throw.

Oh, I'd also add, be careful about the legality of aggressive bezel rings in the countries she's going to be travelling in- you don't want to be causing unnecessary aggravation!

Good luck with your flashlight hunt!
 
Nope, its the only AA light from a reputable manufacturer I have found with a strike bezel.

It was rated by the FL1 standard to 100m of throw, not sure what that translates into for lux at 1 meter.

100 M ANSI throw translates to 2,500 cd, not very strong. For example, I have a 2" long key chain light with 12,000 cd. (cd = lux at one meter)

ANSI throw is to 0.25 lux, which is enough to see the beam hit something, but typically not what it hit at that range.


Why the emphasis on throw, would a flood of light be more useful, or, is the emphasis on blinding an attacker rather than finding something you dropped, etc?

An aggressive strike bezel on a teeny light is sort of useless BTW, and it mostly ends up just poking holes in pockets or purses, etc. A rounded but crenelated bezel can be used lens down as a way to see if its on/provide night light type lighting though.

If you think about the limits on the sizes of the bezel points, and the risk/benefit ratio involved in trying to make a teeny shallow stab wound with the little flashlight vs other courses of action, its probably better to not bother with an aggressive bezel...and to just use a combat knife or other dedicated weapon, or at least pepper spray, etc, if trying to inflict an injury that matters/provides defensive measures.

For example, the use of a light to blind an attacker typically provides only a momentary delay that can be used for escape/buy time to initiate Plan B, etc. Using that brief delay to have that younger female go on the offensive, and close with her attacker to hand to hand combat distances and initiate attempts to inflict teeny bezel cuts, might not be the best Plan A.

:D

AA powered lights are just not that powerful in output, and, while 2.5k cd might be ok at very close range with night adapted eyes to cause a momentary pause...it would be hard pressed to dazzle an attacker at even street light level adaptation.
 
Agree with everything above about the only thing strike bezels are good for, especially on small lights, but how would one of the e2dl's run on two AA's? With their TIR, maybe still good throw even at reduced output vs. Other limited options with a strike bezel? E2dl or e2dl ultra on e2l-aa body?
 
The main emphasis of this thread is to find a strike bezel flashlight to be used as a weapon, if necessary. CPF condones the use of flashlights for all kinds of lighting purposes, and does not recommend the use of a flashlight as a striking weapon. Closing this thread.

Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top