FWIW:
Being annoyed w/ the tiny lanyard hole in the original X5, I broke down and bought a Tactical...first thing, of course, is the stringent empirical comparison test, i.e. which one lights up the 40-foot-away backyard fence better? Hmm...maybe the Tactical's just a wee bit brighter? But, could that be the used 123's in the old 'un versus the new 123's in the Tactical? So, I swapped the batteries. Nope. The Mk 5 Human Eyeball detects no difference in brightness.
The Tactical's just a bit bigger, but I do like the tailswitch for work use, and the ability to fit a useful lanyard*, so it goes into the work pack. Along with a Pelican Versabrite II in case the safety folks get picky, and/or I need both hands to take notes. The "old" X5 goes into the vehicular glovebox.
Ross
*If I guess correctly, the lanyard mod shown on the LED Museum review involves drilling and tapping a camera-mount threaded hole in the end of the old X5, something for which I have neither the tools nor skill.