Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x32650 or 3xAA] Review

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
Reviewer's note : Lumintop SD10 was supplied by Lumintop for review.

The SD10 features a single side switch for activation and mode selection, supporting 3xAA, 1xD, 1x32650 batteries.

S-0.jpg


S-1.jpg


Packaging is a nice cardboard box with cut-out foam. The light comes with a lanyard, spare o-ring, user manual.

Manufacturer Specification from user manual :
• Coated tempered window resists impact.
• Aerospace aluminum uni-body design combined with a stainless steel retaining ring offers superior impact resistance. Mil-Spec hard-anodized. O-ring Sealed.
• Front side switch.
• Superb heat release system provides excellent heat transport capacity.
• Slip-resistant body design.
• Lengthened lanyard hole with tail-standing design.
• Output & runtime
1) 1x32650
Low (10lm / 280h), Med. (100lm / 26hr), High (800lm / 7.5hr)
2) 3xAA
Low (10lm / 150h), Med. (100lm / 15hr), High (500lm / 6hr)
3) 1xD
Low (2lm / 60days), Med. (30lm / 80hr), High (200lm / 7.2hr)
• Dimension : 120.3mm (Length) x 40mm (Dia)
• Weight : 115g
• Impact resistance : 1.5m
• Waterproof : IPX-8 underwater 2m
.
.
S-3.jpg


S-4.jpg


The body plan of the SD10 is fairly straightforward. The light has a simply cylindrical shape.
Black anodizing (type III = HA) is matte finish, and without blemishes on my sample. Lettering is clearly legible in bright white.
.
.
S-5.jpg


The light has 2 parts. The body is one piece with the head (i.e., the body has a built-in head). There is a battery carrier for 3xAA batteries as well.
.
.
S-6.jpg


S-6-1.jpg


The light has a flat stainless steel bezel ring. Below the bezel ring is a black O-ring, holding the lens in place. The head has a clean looking cylindrical design with cooling fins. There's an electronic side switch located near the head. The positive battery contact has a spring. The switch cap is the soft silicone rubber. Switch feel is good feel to touch and has average travel, which produces a definite click sound when pressed. The switch works well.
.
.
S-6-2.jpg


The side switch appears white, but actually has a green LED underneath that lights up every time you press the switch.
.
.
S-7.jpg


The light uses a clean smooth and deep aluminum reflector. I would expect a fairly throw. The XM-L2 T6 emitter is well centered on my sample. The light uses AR coating lens and the purple hue is reflected on it.
.
.
S-8.jpg


Knurling is not so aggressive, but the light has acceptable grip (i.e., it isn't slipperier than expected).
.
.
S-9.jpg


S-10.jpg


S-11.jpg


The light uses a battery carrier to hold the 3xAA cells. It doesn't seem high quality. The material is plastic, aside from the contact plates and springs. But batteries fit securely within the carrier. The 3xAA cells are arranged in series (3S). You can use 1xD cell or 1x32650 Li-ion cell. The working voltage of the light is 0.9~5V. Note the light has no reverse polarity protection function. You should be careful to insert the battery carrier in the correct polarity.
.
.
S-12.jpg


The light has anodized square-cut screw threads for lock-out. Threads feel smooth.
.
.
S-13.jpg


S-14.jpg


There is a slit through a rim which allows for lanyard attachment.
The light can tailstand with the lanyard attached.
.
.
S-15.jpg


From left to right : Eneloop AA, Duracell D, Lumintop SD10, Fenix LD41. The head size & light weight excluding battery are as follows :
SD10 - 39.9mm / 126g, LD41 - 40mm / 178g
.
.
S-16.jpg


The gripability & handling the light is good. The overall build quality is average.
.
.
Measured dimension & weight

S-17.jpg

.
.
User Interface

The light uses an electronic switch for On/Off and mode control.

Holding the switch down for more than 0.5 sec will turn the light on. Another pressing for 0.5 sec will turn the light off.

Press and release to advance through output modes, which proceed in sequence from High ->Med. -> Low, in repeating sequence. The light has mode memory, and remembers the last output level used when you turn the light off and back on, (even after a battery change).

The Strobe is accessed by quick double click. To return to the general mode, just click the switch once, or turn off & on the light. The Strobe has no memory. The light always turns on in the memorized general mode, so there is no danger of strobing accidentally (also it means you can't directly access strobe without turning on the light in general mode first).

User Interface is simple, and I like seeing the Strobe well hidden.
.
.
Standby Current Drain

Due to the electronic side switch interface, the SD10 is drawing a small current when the light is fully connected. I measured this current as 0.46mA with 3xEneloops. That would translate into around 6 months before it would be fully drained. This is negligible in my view, not a concern. But I would recommend you to store the light locked-out.
.
.
PWM
S-18.jpg


There is sign of PWM that I can see, at Low and Med. output levels. But PWM is not present on High output. I notice there is no buzzing sound at all output levels on my sample.
.
.
Runtime
S-19.jpg


S-20.jpg


The runtime to fall to 10% of its initial output from 30 seconds after the point the light is first turned on (i.e., based on ANSI FL-1) for High output is as follows :
1) 1xDuracell 1xD : 276 min.
2) 3xSanyo Eneloop (2000mAh) : 187 min.
3) 1xVicLite 18650 (2600mAh) : 242 min.
I don't have 32650 Li-ion rechargeable cell. I just used 18650 protected cell instead.

The max. output and its runtime with different chemistry & voltage of three batteries are much different. It seems the SD10 steps down on High after 4.5 mins runtime, on both 3xEneloops and 1x18650. The regulation pattern and runtime efficiency of the light seems acceptable.
.
.
Beamshot

1. White door beamshot (about 50cm from the white door)
- ISO100, F/3.5, 1/400sec, Auto white balance
S-21.jpg

.
.
- ISO100, F/3.5, 1/800sec, Auto white balance
S-22.jpg

.
.
- ISO100, F/3.5, 1/1250sec, Auto white balance
S-23.jpg


There is a very soft corona around the small sized bright hotspot. There are a bright thin ring just around the corona and some artifacts in the spill region. But those are not noticeable except up-close. The beam has a typical cool tint. The overall beam quality is good.
.
.
2. Indoor beamshot (about 7.0m from the target on Max. & Min. output)
- ISO100, F/2.8, 1/2sec, Auto white balance
S-24.jpg

- SD10 (Max. output)
.
.
S-25.jpg

- LD41 (Max. output)
.
.
S-26.jpg

.
.
- ISO100, F/2.8, 1/2sec, Auto white balance
S-27.jpg

- SD10 (Min. output)
.
.
S-28.jpg

- LD41 (Min. output)
.
.
S-29.jpg

.
.
3. Outdoor Beamshot (about 55m from the target on Max. output)
- ISO100, F/2.8, 1sec, Auto white balance
S-30.jpg

- Control Shot
.
.
S-31.jpg

- SD10
.
.
S-33.jpg

- LD41
.
.
S-34.jpg

.
.
4. Outdoor Beamshot (about 60~65m from the target on Max. output)
- ISO100, F/2.8, 1sec, Auto white balance
S-35.jpg

- Control Shot
.
.
S-36.jpg

- SD10
.
.
S-37.jpg

- LD41
.
.
S-38.jpg


The light has a reasonable amount of throw.
 
Last edited:

kj2

Flashaholic
Joined
May 22, 2010
Messages
8,082
Location
The Netherlands
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Thanks for the review :)
I was thinking on buying this light, but getting a 32650 battery and charger was to much trouble. Therefore I didn't buy it.
And that battery-carrier looks very cheap. Don't expect that it will hold-up to long.
Do you know with how much mAh (AA and D-cell) they have tested, to get the runtime for the manual?
 
Last edited:

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Thanks for the review :)
I was thinking on buying this light, but getting a 32650 battery and charger was to much trouble. Therefore I didn't buy it.
And that battery-carrier looks very cheap. Don't expect that it will hold-up to long.
Do you know with how much mAh (AA and D-cell) they have tested, to get the runtime for the manual?
Thanks. kj2!
I don't think the batteries carrier is of good quality too. Hope they will upgrade the quality better.
I don't know the capacity of the battereis they used for the test. But they just told me that they used 3.7V Li-ion 32650 rechargeable, 1.5V Alkarine AA cells and 1.5V Alkarine D cell. :confused:
 

monkeyboy

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 7, 2006
Messages
2,327
Location
UK
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Thanks for this excellent and informative review candle lamp.
I was thinking of getting one but don't think I will any more this light has such poor regulation on 1 x li-ion or 3 x eneloop. It looks as if this was done on purpose so they can claim both high output and long runtimes. I can't stand PWM flicker either.
 

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Thanks for this excellent and informative review candle lamp.
I was thinking of getting one but don't think I will any more this light has such poor regulation on 1 x li-ion or 3 x eneloop. It looks as if this was done on purpose so they can claim both high output and long runtimes. I can't stand PWM flicker either.
Thanks for your support. monkeyboy!
It's shame that the light on High mode with li-ion & Ni-MH doesn't show good regulation. The PWM flickering isn't much noticeable with my naked eye. But PWM on Low mode will bother those who are sensitve to PWM.
 

Swedpat

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jan 5, 2008
Messages
3,448
Location
Boden, Sweden
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Thanks candle lamp for the review and runtime graphs! :thumbsup:

I earlier found this light interesting, but according to your test it has the largest brightness drop short from the start I may have ever seen, apart from with 1D cell. Also it's not regulated with any battery configuration. And finally it's PWM at low and mid modes.
For the intention to use it as an emergency light I think it's good because of the possibility to run with several different battery configuration. But I think I will pass in this case.
 

MichaelW

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 8, 2007
Messages
1,788
Location
USA
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Totally need to see how that HDS special D-cell lithium would perform in this.
 

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Thanks candle lamp for the review and runtime graphs! :thumbsup:

For the intention to use it as an emergency light I think it's good because of the possibility to run with several different battery configuration.

Thanks. Swedpat! I'm entirely in agreement with that.

Totally need to see how that HDS special D-cell lithium would perform in this.
Too bad I'm not able to get the 3.0V HDS D-cells here in Korea. I, however, don't expect too much of it.
 

MichaelW

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 8, 2007
Messages
1,788
Location
USA
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

I guess it depends on the voltage where the light switches to the higher output. I bet that with an OCV of about 3 volts, the light would stay in the lower alkaline mode ['200' lumens]. In the alkaline shootout, at 1 amp draw, the voltage of this cell averages to about 2.7 volts. That should perform awesomely, like many hours of flat regulated output.

But for the cost, it is an entirely impractical solution. (unless you win the Lottery)
 
Last edited:

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

I guess it depends on the voltage where the light switches to the higher output. I bet that with an OCV of about 3 volts, the light would stay in the lower alkaline mode ['200' lumens]. In the alkaline shootout, at 1 amp draw, the voltage of this cell averages to about 2.7 volts. That should perform awesomely, like many hours of flat regulated output.
From the runtime graph on High mode on 1x18650 (2600mAh), I guess 3V HDS D-cell will not give much better regulation. I hope that battery will perform much better on Med. or Low mode.
 

JWP_EE

Enlightened
Joined
Apr 22, 2008
Messages
216
Location
New Jersey
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

I got my Lumintop SD10 a few days ago and decided to make some current measurements. I used an older lab supply that
has an analog current meter with 20ma divisions at the low end. I used a digital VOM to measure the voltage.

-------Current(ma)
Volts---LOW--- MID---HIGH--- Watts on HIGH
0.5------------- 80---- 375----- 0.1875
0.6------------- 150--- 720----- 0.432
0.7------------- 200--- 1100---- 0.77
0.8------------- 250--- 1300--- 1.04
0.9------------- 300--- 1650--- 1.485
1.0---- 20----- 340---- 2000--- 2
1.1---- 20----- 360---- 2000--- 2.2
1.2---- 20----- 380---- 2000--- 2.4
1.4---- 20----- 380---- 2000--- 2.8
1.5---- 20----- 260---- 1350--- 2.025
1.6---- 20----- 230---- 1150--- 1.84
1.7---- 20----- 210---- 1000--- 1.7
1.8---- 20----- 200---- 900---- 1.62
1.9---- 20----- 190---- 800---- 1.52
2.0---- 20----- 180---- 750---- 1.5
2.5---- 28----- 150---- 600---- 1.5
3.0---- 48----- 140---- 600---- 1.8
3.2---- 50----- 200---- 800---- 2.8
3.5---- 60----- 330---- 1250--- 4.375
4.0---- 80----- 520---- 2200--- 8.8


I noticed two things as I made the measurements. The light "shifts gears" at about 1.5V and 3.2V.

When on high or medium as the voltage drops the light does not drop down to a lower level. Also be careful when using
3 AA cells because this light works down to about 0.2V and this will cause reverse charging of series cells.

I measured the PWM frequency which is 945Hz.This is high enough to be un-noticeable except for strobe effects on
moving objects.
 
Last edited:

candle lamp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
1,572
Location
South Korea
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Thank you for your measurements and the posting. JWP_EE!
 

Ryp

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
1,381
Location
Canada
Re: Lumintop SD10 [XM-L2, 1xD or 1x18650 or 3xAA] Review

Anyone else think the light (aside from its head) looks like a FourSevens Mini ML?
 
Top