I'll chime in again. Being tech savvy, I'm sure more than a few of us noticed that PC Mag went out of print a month ago, and Computer Shopper is ending it's run on paper in April. Not to mention a zillion other computer magazines gone, like MacUser, Dr. Dobbs, Byte, Mobile Computing, Home PC, Internet World, OS/2 and Personal Computing.
I would guess the failure rate in computer magazines is higher than other general interest titles, because these readers use the internets A LOT. They are on the internets A LOT. They network and learn there, not on paper, and for free. Like we do. So you will always find out more, faster and cheaper, here.
For example, I saw Don's announcement of his new Haiku one nite recently. A couple days later and some anxious refreshing, they were for sale, and I got onboard, paid by Paypal two hours later, and rec'd my new torch in three days. What sort of news would that be for a monthly magazine? Already dead and gone news before it went to print.
It works for Surefire because it's a marketing tool for them, not news and reviews. It works for hunting/outdoors/sporting/LEO titles because their demographic aren't flashaholics, just high-use and demanding users. Someone is yet to convince me it would work for us. You'd be surprised how many scrapbook maniacs or teddy bear fanatics there are. And I bet their internet use is way less than ours.
I once launched a magazine for a small publisher. I don't remember the details, but here today, I'd guess the first year operating costs were probably on the order of $200,000. Now, some of that was recouped by advertising, but the upfront commitment was um, significant.
Anyone with $200K to burn, let me know, I'll help you start a flashlight mag!
daloosh