Sorry, ADMIN, Will reword my post!

Candle Power Forums

Help Support Candle Power:

boltgunner

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Feb 23, 2006
Messages
36
City & State/Province
Houston
My apologies to ADMIN! Bad choice of words, sorry to overstep the rules!

I am looking for suggestions for the ideal flashlight that may be used as a possible last resort for SELF DEFENSE. For a young lady who has to walk at night through a university parking lot. Suggestions, please and thank you!
 
Is she trained in the use of a light for defensive purposes?

There are a LOT of threads that go into great detail on the exact use you describe, and, much of the meat of them involves whether the user would actually know what to do if attacked, etc.

IE: If she's using it to look around to acquire situational awareness, to see if there are people lurking where they seem suspicious, etc...that's one skill set. If she is using it to create a momentary pause in an attack, to gain her time to formulate a counter move, such as running away, a leg sweep, pulling out a .357, or whatever, that involkves another set of skills, and so forth.

If she is attacked and just shines a light at a bad guy, generally, he will be temporarily blinded for a second, or a few, depending on the range and intensity of the light, etc, but, if she is still there a few seconds later, she's in deep doo doo.

And so forth.
 
Last edited:
TEE1 makes a good point. The light is a small piece of a big puzzle.

In order of priority:

1) Avoid the 3 stupids: being around stupid people, going to stupid places, and doing stupid things. These will keep her out of a lot of bad situations. I know that getting drunk is often a big part of the social life on many college campuses, but involves at least one, if not all 3, of the stupids.

2) Awareness/managing unknown contacts at a safe distance. If a low level predator figures out she is on to them and not letting them close enough, they may look for someone else.

3) Unarmed defensive training, preferably based on mixed martial arts. A good MMA school will teach the most pressure-tested techniques for the widest variety of situations in the most efficient manner. The nice thing about unarmed skills is that they are always there, they are never left in the next room, and they are never left behind due to legal or school policy considerations. They can also translate well into improvised weapon skills.

4) To the extent that it may be applicable to her situation, considering both the law in the jurisdiction where the school is located and whatever consequences may exist for violating school policies, a legally carried handgun with appropriate training.

5) Pepper spray. In most places in the US, this will not be an issue either legally or with school policy. Get a spray with an active ingredient rated for at least 2 million Scoville heat units, and a 10% concentration of the active ingredient. A cone-shaped spray pattern is best - it limits the range but maximizes the chances of hitting the eyes at the distances at which attacks take place. Specific recommendations are the Sabre Red Spitfire unit or the ASP Key Defender (also available in a smaller Palm Defender and larger Street Defender).

Regarding lights, the Surefire E2DL and E2DL Ultra are specifically designed with your intended use in mind, and Surefire does build a high quality, durable light. However, the cost of Surefire as compared to other good quality lights, as well as the fact that these lights will go into low mode if turned on within 2 seconds of a previous activation, causes me to hesitate to recommend them. Lately I prefer the FourSevens Quark Tacticals with the XP-G2 emitter (the strobe rate is faster than on Quarks with the XM-L2 emitter), as well as the Klarus XT2C and XT1C. The Quarks are very size efficient, reliable, and can be programmed for one mode with the head loose and another with the head tight. Mine is set for strobe with the head tight and maximum with the head loose, which is ideal for defensive use. The Klarus is a bit larger, but makes both high and strobe instantly available from the tail switch, while preserving access to medium and low. Between the two, I generally prefer the size efficiency and edge in reliability of the Quarks, but find the Klarus user interface to be the best I have ever seen.
 
I wouldn't recommend a flashlight as a tool for self-defense, but if you want something sturdy that might give someone a (false) sense of security then you can't beat a good old-fashioned 4-D Maglite. Light enough to carry, but big and strong enough to make a little girl think she's a MMA fighter.

In the end, the bad guy will walk away with her purse AND her flashlight, but at least the light will just be a crappy old Maglite, and not something expensive!
 
The longer Maglights are a longstanding choice for this purpose. I used to keep a 4D cell Maglight in my car. During a mercifully short time many years ago when I took an "unarmed" security job, a 6D Maglight was a really nice thing to carry around at night. However, I have a tough time picturing a typical college student carrying one around campus.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
The longer Maglights are a longstanding choice for this purpose. I used to keep a 4D cell Maglight in my car. During a mercifully short time many years ago when I took an "unarmed" security job, a 6D Maglight was a really nice thing to carry around at night. However, I have a tough time picturing a typical college student carrying one around campus.

A "flashlight app" on their iPhone probably seems pretty intimidating, though.
 
Anything that is not conveniently carried will be left home, and will be of no value when needed.

So true. Also, at the bottom of a bag that has to be rummaged through to find it is also not going to work in an attack scenario.

If it's inconvenient to carry, or access quickly, it's not effective.

A kid carting around a Billy club on campus will not be likely to go over well.
 
So true. Also, at the bottom of a bag that has to be rummaged through to find it is also not going to work in an attack scenario.

If it's inconvenient to carry, or access quickly, it's not effective.

A kid carting around a Billy club on campus will not be likely to go over well.

When walking around shady areas, I already have my Klarus ST20 palmed in my left hand in 'tacticool' hammer fist grip with a finger on the clicky. Also, I'm constantly looking around for exit routes and potential unfriendlies. You don't need much training to run, but you will at least need the mindset to do so. In most fight or flight situations, 'fly, you fools!' Sometimes, even the brightest light stick around won't save you no matter how much training you have.
 
Back
Top