Thanks for the comparison. It's actually made quite a bit of difference. I always assumed that an incan lamp, even a known good quality one like the P60, was deteriating right from the start. If a 20+ hour lamp seems more or less like a new lamp, for me it makes a stock P60 light much more of a user than just a backup type light.
I do have incan rechargeable options, (Lumens factory 3.7v lamps, 17670 batteries) but I just really like the ease and simplicity of P60, 2 primaries, stock light like a 6P. It makes a great combo, which is probably why Surefire sell it that way I suppose!