Transistor possibly damaged; replace?

Candle Power Forums

Help Support Candle Power:

Flatscan

Enlightened
Joined
Jul 30, 2002
Messages
223
I replaced the power transistor on the board in my bike light with a higher rated, larger one. It handles high/low/off to the light, which is a BB500 driving two 3W TV1Js. There's some background info here, but it's not really necessary.

The new transistor is a Radio Shack TIP31 NPN transistor in a TO-220 case. It works great as a replacement, handling both high and low modes without excessive heat (it gets noticeably lukewarm after 1-2 minutes, and definitely warm in 5 minutes).

However, I was metering it in operation, and I managed to short L+ and L- through the multimeter in current mode. The batteries were around 4.6V under high-mode load (around 861mA to BB, 1380mA from batteries) before the mistake. The path was battery, transistor (collector-emitter), multimeter. I realized something was wrong when the emitters turned off, so the short was in place for up to a second. Not completely understanding, I left the light running for 15 more seconds, then I noticed a funny smell. It took me a few more seconds to identify the transistor as the source and to burn myself on it; then I cut power.

The multimeter and the transistor seem to be okay. The multimeter measures up to 4A, and its fuse didn't blow. The transistor, once allowed to cool down, performs exactly as it used to. Its relevant max ratings are Ic = 3A and dissipation = 20W.

Should I worry about the transistor and just replace it now? Once I finish building the light, it will be very difficult to replace anything. The heatsink will be epoxyed into place in the headlight body, and the transistor's back will be AA'd to back of the heatsink. In normal use, the transistor shouldn't get much hotter than warm, if the heatsink is as effective as hoped.
 
if the trasistor is cheap just replace it. It's been my experance, once something like that has had that level of heat stress it can shorten it's usefull life, it may work fine now and fail a month from now, it may work fine for years, but why take the chance if it's a cheap part
 
[ QUOTE ]
Draco_Americanus said:
if the trasistor is cheap just replace it. It's been my experance, once something like that has had that level of heat stress it can shorten it's usefull life, it may work fine now and fail a month from now, it may work fine for years, but why take the chance if it's a cheap part

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree, replace it now while it's still accessible. I've seen heat stress problems in semiconductors where the tiny bond pads on the chip die become partially or fully desoldered, causing the chip to act as a thermal oscillator... when it's cold, it conducts and the device works, but as it warms up and the tiny gold wires inside bend, the pads disconnect and the device goes open circuit, causing it to cool down, then conduct again once it's cold, then warm up and open again... blink... blink... /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/icon15.gif
 
Back
Top