I have to agree that the Mag has a further throw because it can be focused tighter. The Tigerlight has more output though, and is actually a more useful beam, especially with the newer bulbs. Since I've been using my Mag to search cars, I wished I'd have bought the FBOP Tigerlight instead of my Mag, but the Mag is better than the Stinger HP's we have issued. And of course, if I have to try and find some terrorist that has breache the fence at night, the Mag will reach into the shadows a bit more. Not as nice as the Thors that the QRF and some guard towers have of course, but not too shabby.