At 1m, a randomly selected Jet-I Pro IBS with OP was showing 4700 lux on my EA30, while my R2 with SMO was showing 3820. Both were using AW P14500 batteries. In my admitedly limted R2 sample, the spot is also 30% or so wider on the IBS, and both the spill and overall output are about 50% brighter (confirmed with measurements at a point mid-way out on the spill, and with ceiling bounce tests).
I've seen 4300 lux @ 1m in Selfbuilt's R2 test, and 4500 lux elsewhere, so even if you take those tests as representative and not as potentially hand picked samples, the R2 SMO vs the IBS OP isn't a net loss in throw. I have tested a few Jet-I Pro IBS's that exceed 5500 lux @1m, so the one I tested above was certainly not specifically selected by me for this test.
Side by side the R2 SMO can seem to out throw the IBS, but given the above lux numbers it is likely just a combined phsychological artifact of the tighter spot, the sharper edges to the spot, and the physical impact of how this results in greater pupil dilation due to higher overall illumination.
Regards,
Eric