Something must not be coming through in my wording. I don't know how else to explain it so it makes sense, so I apologize if my post was offensive.
By putting three question marks I was implying that it was an open ended question with no right answer, Not that my stance was right and yours was wrong. Maybe it came through that way.
I don't think there is a right or wrong way to make a flashlight, just different ways that appeal to different people. That's why I wrote "Who is right???" Because no one can answer that for anyone else. No one is absolutely right.
One person may love SOS and 1000 lumens and another person may hate SOS and want a small light that is not so bright and has good runtime. Shouldn't there be flashlights for both people? To say that the "engineers must be joking themselves if they think 150 lumens is enough" implies that anyone who wants a 150 lumen light is wrong for buying it. Calling their posts "nonsense" is more than a little inflammatory. Don't you suppose that they introduce new lights to satisfy customer requests for a product they don't currently have? I assume this light fills such a need.
Fenix has been going strong for many years now, they must be doing something right.
Anyways, we're pretty far off topic here, and I don't want to have to Ban myself, so I'll just leave it at that. Haha. I hope I have clarified my point some though. I'm defending people's right to choose, whatever that choice may happen to be. Bright, dim, blinky, large, small, cheap, expensive, whatever.