MBentz
Enlightened
hmmm, I have lights with twisty head (Eagletac), control rings (Sunwayman/Niteye), and double button on the base (Fenix).
I dislike the twisty head especially with more than one level via twisting since the on/off button moves when the head is twisted, and that forces me to change my hand position. If the on/off button remains maybe in the base and the head twist simply is a high/low, then sort of OK. Furthermore, I am barely able to twisting the head with my thumb + forefinger.
With a control ring, I can easily move the ring with my thumb + forefinger, or maybe even just one of them. The major negative to the control ring is possible dirt contamination under the rotating ring.
The double button on the base - one for on/off, one for level - is a problem of finding the correct button by feel in the dark and maybe with gloves on. Yes, once used to the smaller/lower button being the level button, not that bad. However with all of the controls in the base, I have to hold the light in an overhand position, which is rather awkward at times.
Arguably a button method is the best for resisting dirt contamination.
Thank you for your thoughts moldyoldy. I have large hands so I do not think about being unable to easily change modes with something like the SX25L3. Honestly though, is single handed operation that imperative, especially on a non-EDC light? If it were, I would think a headlamp would be a better tool in that situation.
I've yet to try out a light with an on/off button next to a mode switch button. Actually, I think I would like that quite a bit. I just can't get over the fact that Fenix's lights are quite possibly the most ugly designed lights currently in production. There are some exceptions, like the TM and SRT series, but overall I think their lights are not aesthetically pleasing with lower build quality.
Oh well, to each their own. I'm glad we have so many choices in lights these days. I hope many people are happy with this light. More lights based off the MT-G2 is a good thing.