Ok so I realised I want at least two lights (haha!!) and need to pick one to start with...
My 1st priority is a non-compact 18650 with only modest throw and a wide beam, serious toughness, and a nasty looking bezel.
I think I've picked the TK22 to meet these requirements
The TK16 is also a contendor and it is more floody.
Closest looking nitecore was the old p16?
My 2nd priority is a compact or semi-compact 1x18650 again with modest throw.
SC62 - floody and one of the smallest options
SC600 mk iii - unprotected 18650 only
people reporting green tints (yuck) don't want to have to buy unprotected and in future protected for other lights...
SC600 mk ii - contendor, bit more throw than sc62
P12 - 1000/240/70/11 - (really 900) - physical reverse protection only. Not sure I like the mode spacing. Fairly narrow beam spread compared to the others.
P12GT - probably too throwy for my needs, pd35 is a bit more efficient it seems. Fairly narrow beam spread compared to the others.
PD35 - 850/450/170/45/10 - contendor
MH20 - no head spring - after dropping a torch on its head and killing it due to the battery damaging the pcb, don't want to go down this path. Great light though, good beam.
TN12 - looked at the 2014 version reviewed by selfbuilt but its not really a stellar performer for efficiency and is kind of direct drive in max/high.
G25C2-II - no lockout - maybe not ok with flattops (saw this mentioned somewhere)
TX25C2 - beam is too narrow for my tastes