Pizzaman, you may be very correct in your assessment.
I bought most of my EVERLED's at one time for 3-D Cell mag-lites. I still have the 2-D mag-lite that I bought 25 years ago when I was in the Coast Guard.
We had a couple extended power failures a few years ago. And while I love groping my wife in the dark as much as the next guy, I thought It was time to put Mag-lites in both car, one in each of the three bedrooms, One in the Garage, and one in the kitchen closet.
I had never heard of CPF at that time, so I purchased Side-Emitters EverLED's based upon advertisements I read in magazines.
I put the Everled's into the Mag-lites, and I had mixed emotions.
1. I loved the extended battery life.
2.I didnt have to buy a D cell for a very long time.
3. They were brighter than the standard bulbs that came with the 2-D cell Mag-Lites.
4. Except for the yellowish tint to one of them they were amazingly white.
On the flip side, I thought they should have been brighter. So I soon replaced them with three watt Diamond LED bulbs. While the light was not quite triple, that of the one watts, they were noticably brighter.
So after upgrading the mag-lites I had seven EVERLED's that I didn't know what to do with. I thought about Ebay, but my terciary flashlight for caving was a fulton MX/991/u. aka, a very durable flashlight, even when caked in cave mud 2-d flashlight.
I hosed off the fulton angle-light stuck a side-emitter EVERLED into one, and man was it bright. It left the krypton in the dust, and when I dropped it, it didn't pop.
I can't say that the reflector accidentally was positioned correctly for the side-emitter EverLED's, or a Lambertian emitter would have been much brighter in my military issue indestructo flashlight. I did not have a Lambertian EverLED to make the comparison with. But compared to the stock krypton bulb that comes with the Fulton, the side emitter EverLED rocks and rolls. Like laser beams in my dreams.
I had 6 EverLED's left, and one in my caving backup to my backup. I still didn't know what to do with all my precious EverLED's, them came the call-ups. 5 of my friends were off to war, and my son was off to Boy Scout Summer Camp.
I gave each of my friends a Desert Tan flashlight with an EverLED (Side Emitter) to take to the Middle East. They too were ignorant of Lambertian emitters. I doubt if any of them could even pronounce Lambertian. After all they are all a bunch of Tennessee Rednecks that just wanted to kick Al Quida Butt.
And my son Jacob wanted a black Fulton to take to Boy Scout summer camp. So I fixed him up. I made him promise (with threats of death) to take good care of it, and bring it home safely. Death threats with Jake never work. His flashlight is still either laying in the mud somewhere at Camp Buck Toms, or it found it's way into another person's foot locker. That is about the 5th flashlight of mine that he let get lost or stolen. Typical for a 13 year old.
That all said, I found CPF forums, and my next Fulton MX991/U will arrive tomorrow. Electro-lumens put one together for me with a three watt Luxeon and tweaked it for brightness. I can't wait to play with it.
Also since I joined CPF, all of my TerraLUX TL-5's for mini-maglights started being put into other peoples Mini-maglights when they weren't watching.
They all think that they have blinding flashlights now. But I dumped them, because I found an advertiser on CPF called the sandwich shoppe that introduced me to a New, brighter Madmax non-adjustable, wide-open, semi Voltage regulated 2AA Flashlight Kit: including a Madmax Plus Module with Luxeon LXHL-PW09 (White Lux III emitter), optics, o-ring and Sandwich retaining o-rings. Now my 2-AA flashlight rocks too.
If anyone tries a Fulton flashlight with a Lambertian emitter compared to a star emitter, I would really like to know how they compare.
Dan