I had the opportunity to play with one of these things over the weekend. My brother bought one and I have to say I was quite impressed. But, I think the debate over the iPad harkens back to the days when I first decided to make the switch over to a Mac vs. a PC.
To make this short and to the point, I purchased my Mac about 2 years ago. I'm glad I've made the switch and I can honeslty say I'll never go back to a PC. The main reason for my decision was pretty much based upon a post that I placed here on CPF. When my PC crashed, I placed a post here in the Cafe soliciting opinions. The results were astonishing. Almost all of the PC guys said to do this, to do that, run this software, run that software, did I check this/that, I should change to this, upgrade to that... blah blah blah. All the Mac guys said was....."Buy a Mac. You'll never look back."
That pretty much settled it for me. It was quite clear that the PC guys loved to tinker with their machines and really enjoyed problem solving and getting into the nitty gritty detail of optimizing thier machines and tricking them out. They are equivalent to the Hot-Rodders out there that love to tinker with their cars. Totally nothing wrong with that, some people just love the challenge and see computers almost as a hobby.
I'm a bit different, I simply want to surf the internet, use a spreadsheet, type a letter, transfer a file and set up my iPod. And I want all this to work flawlessly. I'm not a hot-rodder and I don't want to tinker. I want the machine to work, boringly like a Honda (no offence to Honda owners. They make good reliable cars which is why I used the example.) My iMac has been just that. I took the computer out of the box, plugged it in and its been running flawlessly ever since I turned it on. No viruses, no crashes, no goofiness. It just works. I'm quite sure there are tons of folks out there that tinker with ther Macs too, but for me, I have not had to talk to my IT folks at work for over two years. Again, it just works.
So that brings me to the iPad. For me, I see the iPad as a simple extension of my existing computer. It would allow me to surf the internet, check my email, check on CPF, view video, look up phone numbers, check the weather while I'm not exactly at my iMac. Its a simple device, that allows me to do some of the more mundane and non-technical things without being tied to my desk. For those people even less computer savy than I.... for example my Mom... this may actually serve as a complete replacement for her computer.
For me, I think the heavier duty tasks will still be up to the iMac, but for what it is the iPad is a pretty cleaver device, that can fit the bill as an extension of your existing computer.
If you need Flash or want to do more "tinkering" then by all means this device is not for you. A PC laptop is probably cheaper and can do more. But for a slick running, and simple, intuitive device that frees you from your desktop, the iPad is worth a closer look.
I think Apple is really onto something here and I'm quite certain you will see more and more touch based devices iwith more and more capabilities in the very near future.
Call it a game changer may be a bit much, but I have to say... Another hats off to Apple. I think the iPad definitely has a place around the MSax compound.
YMMV.
MSax