That's quite a difference, using the same head.
I've noticed a lack of consistency in the LEDs used by Fenix. I had 3 L1Ts from the same batch, and all three are VERY different. The best one has a pure white tint, and is very bright and throws great on 1AA, that's my EDC. Its brightness is something between the two pictures above, with perfect tint.
The second is the one I took the pics above. It has a slight cooler blue tint, but very normal for a LED, wouldn't bother 99% of us, but not as bright as the first one. I guess that's the standard Q2 brightness, it's good for me. This one has a perfect centered LED.
I'm currently using this head in my L2T.
The third one was crap, it wasn't as bright as the other two, and I ended up selling it.
The L2D Q5 I bought was so lame I returned it.
Now I'm afraid to buy any Fenix light from any store out of my country, because I don't know what I will get and returning it would be a hassle.
There's only one store that sells Fenix in Brazil, and they don't have all models available. But their service is great, no questions asked returning policy.